9 Accepted

Defra already has challenges and pressures over the next few years and has potentially substantial...

Conclusion
Defra already has challenges and pressures over the next few years and has potentially substantial further forthcoming change. Defra assured us that it was able to take on the challenges and that it had the skills and resources to lead these changes.16 Defra will need to prove that it does have the skills and resources to deliver the scale of regulatory change that the country needs. This is particularly challenging as some regulations and objectives are in competition, such as prioritising water quality as opposed to food production. Defra told us it was pleased with the progress it has made since the NAO report from 2023 on reviewing and revising existing regulations, but recognised that improving the regulatory system will be an ongoing endeavour.17 However, the scale of change required is substantial, and Defra and the regulators are not meeting even current demands effectively.18 Written evidence we received, in particular from Arbtech, an ecological consultancy, raised concerns about the capacity and capability of the environmental regulators to deliver their existing commitments, as well as to perform new duties.19 11 Q 4 12 Q 8 13 Qq 2-3 and 5 14 Q 3 15 Q 44 16 Q 7 17 Qq 19 and 43 18 Qq 3 and 9 19 Arbtech (ENR0011) 10 Defining what regulation should achieve and how
Government Response Summary
The government acknowledges the concerns about effectiveness and resourcing, stating it is 'already delivering' a coordinated reform programme. This programme integrates recommendations from several reviews and includes initiatives like Lead Environmental Regulator (LER) pilots and new Strategic Policy Statements to strengthen regulators' culture, capability, and decision-making.
Government Response
Accepted
HM Government Accepted
1.2 Defra is already delivering a coordinated programme of reform that addresses the Committee’s concerns about the effectiveness, coherence and resourcing of environmental regulation. This programme brings together the implementation of recommendations from the Corry Review, the Independent Water Commission, and the internal Optimising Delivery (Hancock) Review, alongside wider government regulatory reform activity, with a focus on prioritising reforms that will deliver the greatest impact. 2.5 In addition, Defra is delivering ambitious, system-wide reforms arising from the Corry Review and the internal Optimising Delivery (Hancock) Review. These reforms prioritise action within existing legislative frameworks to promote joint working (such as LER pilots) and to strengthen culture, capability and decision-making within regulators (including through new Strategic Policy Statements for the Environment Agency and Natural England). Defra is also testing more integrated, place-based approaches through pathfinders with Mayoral Combined Authorities and protected landscape organisations.
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age 0.3 yrs
Report published 25 Mar 2026