16 Accepted

We were concerned that Greensill had approached various parts of government looking for financial support,...

Conclusion
We were concerned that Greensill had approached various parts of government looking for financial support, with different decision-makers arriving at conclusions in isolation and without engaging with officials in other departments. For example, the Bank told us that it was not in touch with UKEF during its accreditation of Greensill, but that it had “looked at … and questioned” the same media reports that UKEF had identified during its due diligence.45 The Bank told us the fact that it and UKEF reached different conclusions from the same media reports reflected the different eligibility criteria of the two schemes.46 The Treasury explained that because each of the business support schemes that Greensill applied to were designed with “different objectives in mind and with different rules” and eligibility criteria, it was not surprised that different conclusions were reached.47
Government Response Summary
The government agrees and states the recommendation is implemented. BEIS will work closely with Cabinet Office and HM Treasury to develop existing processes for sharing company information across government departments and public bodies, while respecting commercial and legal restrictions.
Government Response
Accepted
HM Government Accepted
1.1 The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation. Recommendation implemented 1.2 The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) has written to the Committee on this matter alongside this Treasury Minute. 1.3 BEIS (the department) recognises that sharing information on companies across government and between public bodies can bring benefits for policymaking, service delivery, and efforts to mitigate financial crime. The department already plays an active role in facilitating this practice across government in a sensible and proportionate way, where permitted by law and with regard for the appropriate balance of sensitivities and interests. 1.4 BEIS has raised the importance of this across other departments that are responsible for coordinating business information and will work closely with Cabinet Office and HM Treasury to develop existing processes where necessary, bearing in mind commercial and legal restrictions. 1.5 The department also works closely with its arms-length bodies, including Companies House and the Insolvency Service, on appropriate data sharing, for example in response to fraud in the Bounce Back Loan Scheme. 1.6 The department keeps its internal processes under regular review.
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age 4.7 yrs
Report published 20 Nov 2021