Third Report - “We’re going to need a bigger Navy”

Select Committee
Defence Committee HC 168 14 December 2021
Report Status Government responded
Conclusions & Recommendations 29 items (23 recs)
Government Response (AI assessment · 29 of 29 classified)
Government response
Fifth Special Report - “We’re going to need a bigger Navy”: Government Response to the Committee’s Third Report · published 25 Feb 2022

Recommendations & Conclusions

8 results
3 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 46
The Navy cannot fulfil the full ambition of the Integrated Review with its current fleet.
Recommendation
The Navy cannot fulfil the full ambition of the Integrated Review with its current fleet. It needs more lower-end, adaptable vessels, like the planned Type 31 frigate, to fulfil the presence operations planned. A large part of the Government’s plan … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government outlines commitments to procure new Type 31, Type 32, Type 26, FSS, and Multi-Role Support Ships, stating this will increase overall vessel numbers by 2030, addressing the need for fleet growth, particularly with adaptable vessels, though not explicitly committing to the committee's scale of increase or new funding.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
5 Recommendation Accepted in Part
The Indo-Pacific tilt is a significant change in the UK’s defence posture which will increase...
Recommendation
The Indo-Pacific tilt is a significant change in the UK’s defence posture which will increase the demand and risk placed on finite resources. We will consider the value and effectiveness of the overall tilt policy and greater engagement in the … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government stated it intends to deploy a Carrier Strike Group annually, but clarified that each deployment will be bespoke in terms of objectives, composition, and allied involvement. It did not explicitly address the request for public transparency on the overall costs of the Indo-Pacific tilt.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
10 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 79
The delivery of digital and data integration like the Naval Strike Network will be absolutely...
Recommendation
The delivery of digital and data integration like the Naval Strike Network will be absolutely crucial if the fleet is to be operated effectively. The Department must ensure that the Naval Strike Network is fully funded and compatible with Defence’s … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government reassured the Committee that the Naval Strike Network will be fully compliant with Defence’s digital backbone, but stated that the Royal Navy is still exploring opportunities to fully fund this capability.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
15 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 111
Building interoperability with nations in the Indo-Pacific will be vital for delivering any tilt to...
Recommendation
Building interoperability with nations in the Indo-Pacific will be vital for delivering any tilt to the region. This must include coordinating with European partners and working to rebuild the military relationship with France. The Navy must continue to regularly exercise … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states it has a mature strategy for the Pacific, detailing existing deployments and collaboration efforts, but explicitly confirms the UK ceased participation in Operation ATALANTA in March 2019 due to a lack of legal basis.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
18 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 127
Reporting of availability must improve to avoid concealing issues with the availability of specific classes...
Recommendation
Reporting of availability must improve to avoid concealing issues with the availability of specific classes of vessel. The Ministry of Defence should report annually to Parliament in a written statement on the availability of all surface vessels in the Royal … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government committed to providing a single annual update to the Defence Committee on Surface Fleet availability and shipbuilding plans, but did not explicitly confirm the separate annual written statement to Parliament or all the specific details requested for the classified report.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
24 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 156
Proper scrutiny is essential to ensure programmes are delivered on time.
Recommendation
Proper scrutiny is essential to ensure programmes are delivered on time. In order to allow for proper scrutiny of ongoing programmes, the Ministry of Defence should emulate the US Department of Defense and provide Parliament with an annual shipbuilding plan, … Read more
Government Response Summary
The department will provide a single annual update to the Defence Committee, which will include Surface Fleet availability and shipbuilding plans, but does not explicitly commit to the 30-year plan, individual SRO reports, or public evidence sessions requested.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
25 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 176
The National Shipbuilding Strategy refresh must finally take on board the consistent recommendations given in...
Recommendation
The National Shipbuilding Strategy refresh must finally take on board the consistent recommendations given in successive reports by a range of experts. This includes providing a steady pipeline of work for British shipyards and working collaboratively with industry. The refresh … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government committed to addressing the skills aspect of the National Shipbuilding Strategy refresh by conducting an assessment of current requirements and outlining how various bodies will collaborate to deliver necessary skills, but did not address the other five specific recommendations.
Ministry of Defence
View Details
27 Recommendation Accepted in Part
Para 184
We welcome the Department’s ambition to bring new technology into the fleet and the opportunities...
Recommendation
We welcome the Department’s ambition to bring new technology into the fleet and the opportunities that the large number of planned vessels offer. It provides an early test of the new Integrated Operating Concept. It is essential that NavyX and … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government outlined how DE&S and NavyX address technological development and digital system integration through open architectures and application-based software, committing to their use in future vessel designs. It also stated the Royal Navy would specifically review funding allocated for research, development, and engineering as part of its annual budget cycle.
Ministry of Defence
View Details