Sarah Gibbs
PFD Report
All Responded
Ref: 2020-0220
Emergency services related deaths (2019 onwards)
Hospital Death (Clinical Procedures and medical management) related deaths
All 1 response received
· Deadline: 24 Dec 2020
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Inadequate communication between staff teams, especially during night handovers, and uncertainty regarding the consistent use of effective communication tools like SBARD were identified.
View full coroner's concerns
Concerns were raised during the inquest with regard to communication between teams, particularly to the staff on duty at night as to what information was handed over. Evidence was heard of an easy to use form of communication tool which enables information to be transferred accurately, especially at handover time, between nurses and clinicians, known as SBARD. This helps in reducing the likelihood for errors in communication information. It was not known whether this tool is in use although it was “hoped” it is being used. This is some eighteen months following Miss Gibbs’s death.
Responses
Action Taken
SBARD is integrated into the patient handover used by the wards at every handover, with a template document used. EObs has been introduced. The Recognise and Response Team (RRT) has been expanded to provide their services 24/7 and teaches SBARD on all new staff inductions. (AI summary)
SBARD is integrated into the patient handover used by the wards at every handover, with a template document used. EObs has been introduced. The Recognise and Response Team (RRT) has been expanded to provide their services 24/7 and teaches SBARD on all new staff inductions. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Mrs Lake Sarah Nadine Louise GIBBS I write to formally respond to the Regulation 28: Report to Prevent Future Deaths issued following this inquest in October 2020. I apologise on behalf of the Trust for the delay: no disrespect was intended. I understand that (Trust Solicitor) has already written to your team to explain how this occurred. It is now my intention to provide you with the information that was originally collated and to update you with regards to the position now. During the inquest, a concern was raised "with regard to communication between teams, particularly to the staff on duty at night as to what information was handed over. Evidence was heard of an easy to use form of communication tool which enables information to be transferred accurately, especially at handover time, between nurses and clinicians, known as SBARD. This helps in reducing the likelihood for errors in communication information. It was not known whether this tool is in use although it was "hoped" it is being used." December 2020 SBARD is a structured form of communication that consists of standardised prompt questions in four sections: S (Situation); 8 (Background); A (Assessment) and R (Recommendation). It can also include a final section, D (Decision). As at December 2020, staff were encouraged and trained to use SBARD as a communication method across the hospital. In some areas, there were posters displaying how the tool benefits communication and what the tool is with the steps clearly laid out. These were first issued by the Critical Care Outreach Team. SBARD was consistently used for the presentation of cases to SIG and providing information in response to enquiries for the CQC. There was not the evidence
available to provide assurance that this communication tool was in consistent and regular use with patient facing teams for escalating concerns. The Trust was also planning to undertake a large scale digital improvement project to implement eObs and a clinical messaging system to improve the escalation of deteriorating patients to response teams. In addition, we were planning to expand the Recognise and Respond team with their remit to include training and education. December 2022 SBARD is integrated into the patient handover used by the wards at every handover. There is a template document used with each section of the SBAR tool to be completed by staff. This has been in place at the Trust for approximately 18 months. EObs has been introduced at the Trust. Since June 2021, the Recognise and Response Team (RRT) has been expanded to provide their services 24/7. The RRT works across inpatient wards responding to acutely deteriorating patients, attending resuscitation calls in the hospital as well as delivering education, training and quality improvement projects. The RRT lead in the education and training of Trust staff in the assessment and management of acutely unwell patients, providing basic, intermediate and advanced resuscitation courses and bespoke acute deteriorating patient courses for medical students, doctors, nurses, midwives and HCAs. The RRT teach SBARD on all new staff inductions; Assess, Communicate, Treat Courses; ALERT course; HCA study day; and BEACH course, as well as ad hoc ward training. The t eam are about to launch a new NEWS2 e-learning course which also teaches SBARD. I hope the information provided within this letter reassures you about the steps taken to implement SBARD into our processes and to improve communication between teams.
available to provide assurance that this communication tool was in consistent and regular use with patient facing teams for escalating concerns. The Trust was also planning to undertake a large scale digital improvement project to implement eObs and a clinical messaging system to improve the escalation of deteriorating patients to response teams. In addition, we were planning to expand the Recognise and Respond team with their remit to include training and education. December 2022 SBARD is integrated into the patient handover used by the wards at every handover. There is a template document used with each section of the SBAR tool to be completed by staff. This has been in place at the Trust for approximately 18 months. EObs has been introduced at the Trust. Since June 2021, the Recognise and Response Team (RRT) has been expanded to provide their services 24/7. The RRT works across inpatient wards responding to acutely deteriorating patients, attending resuscitation calls in the hospital as well as delivering education, training and quality improvement projects. The RRT lead in the education and training of Trust staff in the assessment and management of acutely unwell patients, providing basic, intermediate and advanced resuscitation courses and bespoke acute deteriorating patient courses for medical students, doctors, nurses, midwives and HCAs. The RRT teach SBARD on all new staff inductions; Assess, Communicate, Treat Courses; ALERT course; HCA study day; and BEACH course, as well as ad hoc ward training. The t eam are about to launch a new NEWS2 e-learning course which also teaches SBARD. I hope the information provided within this letter reassures you about the steps taken to implement SBARD into our processes and to improve communication between teams.
Sent To
- Norfolk and Norwich University Hospital
Response Status
Linked responses
1 of 1
56-Day Deadline
24 Dec 2020
All responses received
About PFD responses
Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.
Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary
Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 25/04/2019 I commenced an investigation into the death of Sarah Nadine Louise GIBBS aged 38. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 26/10/2020. The medical cause of death was: 1a) Aspiration of Gastric Contents 1b) Vomiting 1c) 1d) Acute Peritonitis Following Recent Insertion of PEG tube to Assist Nutrition (in patient with learning disabilities and epilepsy) The conclusion of the inquest was: Sarah Gibbs died shortly after returning home following a medical procedure.
Circumstances of the Death
Sarah Gibbs had learning disabilities, lacked mental capacity and had difficulty feeding. She underwent a PEG operation on 16 April 2019. Sarah was discharged home on 17 April 2019. The result of an earlier blood test was not known and she was not seen by a Doctor immediately prior to discharge. Later that day, Sarah became unresponsive and emergency services were called. A defibrillator was not able to be accessed. Sarah was pronounced dead at the scene.
Similar PFD Reports
Reports sharing organisations, categories, or themes
Related Inquiry Recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes
Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.