Cynthia Fretwell

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2013-0366
Date of Report 16 December 2013
Coroner Jane Gillespie
Coroner Area Nottinghamshire
Response Deadline est. 10 February 2014
All 1 response received · Deadline: 10 Feb 2014
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
The GP practice had an ineffective system for telephone referrals, lacking timely consultation, proper assessment of patient mental capacity for refusing treatment, and clear communication between staff and doctors.
View full coroner's concerns
_ In the circumstances_ it is my statutory duty to report to you: (1) Telephone referrals and the lack of an effective system for conveying and responding to information between the caller and the doctor: Specifically, had concerns about the following aspects: day gall gall Mrs a) The inability of reception staff to interrupt GP during surgery for the purposes of alerting and informing the doctor of a change in the patient s condition following a telephone referral, (b) Timely consultation and timely responses to telephone referrals from patients and their families (c) The threshold for determining whether a telephone consultation is adequate Or whether a home consultation should be undertaken (2) A full assessment of the patients mental capacity in a situation where are refusing medical treatment or admission to hospital.

(3) Full and proper documentation of the discussions between the doctor and the patientipatient's family in those circumstances_ In the course of oral evidence taken at the inquest on the 18.10.2013, was informed of changes that had been instituted by the Hama Medical Centre since the death of Mrs Fretwell which would address these concerns_ adjourned the inquest on 16th October 2013 to provide an opportunity to the Hama Medical Centre to commit the detail of changesto writing_ asked that a report to be filed by 4pm on 30"h October 2013 ad the matter was re-listed on 12th November 2013. received a report from the Hama Medical Centre dated 218' October 2013_ was satisfied from the contents of that letter ad its attachments that matters 1(a) & (b) of the concerns above had been addressed_ However, there was no reference to the remaining issues Of concern which had been identified. In the circumstances therefore, consider the response inadequate and feel my duty to report has been invoked.
Responses
Hama Medical Centre Other
19 Dec 2013
Action Taken
Hama Medical Centre has updated its Mental Capacity Act 2005 policy and updated its Telephone Consultation Protocol, in addition to discussing the Mental Capacity Act during medical meetings. They have also included a full assessment of the patient's mental capacity in a situation where they are refusing medical treatment or admission to hospital in accordance with guidelines in the Practice's mental capacity policy. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Miss Gillespie; Re: Cynthia Fretwell (deceased) dob 28.6.1928 Late of 7 Croft Crescent; Awsworth; Nottinghamshire Further to Regulation 28 report to prevent future deaths dated 19.12.2013, the Practice has discussed this case aS a Significant Event: The discussions have taken place during Medical meetings on several occasions, in the presence Of GP s, Practice Nurses, Reception Manager and Practice manager. As a result of OUr discussions; the following steps have been laken: The Practice has updated its MENTAL CAPACITY ACT 2005 POLICY. This is saved 0n the shared for all the to access it as necessary_ See attached. 2 A summary of the Mental capacity Act 2005 in also saved 0n the shared drive` for more detailed reference. Telephone Consultation Protoeol has been updated and copy of this has been submitted to Your office and been accepted by yourself: We have discussed the Mental Capacity Act during our Medical Meetings So that we are all updated 0n it. Particular attention has been to sections relating to the Principles of the Act; Purposes of the Act and Best interests, as highlighted in the copy Of summary of Mental Capacity Act attached. 5_ Attention is also paid to 5 core principles, basic rccording; assessment of capacity and assessment of capacity checklist in the Practice s Mental capacity act policy have previously attended Protected Learning time event on 23.5.2013 on Safeguarding Children and vulnerable adults, Mental Hama Medical Centre is the trading name of HMC (Kimberley) Limited Registered No: 8244108 This practice is & member of the Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group, group of local NHS practices, making iocal dccisions for local people NHS Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group drive staff paid

Hama Medical Centre 11 Nottingham Road, Kimberley, Nottingham NG16 2NB Telephone 0115 9382101 Fax 0115 9459208 Website: wwuhamamedicakcentrecouk Capacity Act and PREVENT: This event addressed the principles and application of the Mental Capacity Act, amongst Other issues: will continue to keep themselves updated by attending appropriate future courses wvill be attending such course in the near future. The Practice staff have attended a course to learn about Mental capacity Act in 2009 and will update themselves with e-learning this subject On *blue stream academy" The Praetice answers YOur queries in Ic, 2 and 3 as follows: Ic: The Practice will adopt a very low threshold for home visiting: This would especially be $0 in a patient who has not been seen face to face previously, in the elderly if the illness was on going Or if there was any doubt whatsoever about the nature of medical problem on the phone_ 2 A full assessment of the patient'$ mental capacity in a situation where are refusing medical treatment or admission to hospital will be made in accordance with guidelines in the Practice' $ mental capacity policy attached, If the clinical situation warranted hospitalisation GP would, with the help of the family, encourage the patient t0 go into hospital. If the patient refused, GP would reinforce the need for hospitalisation and the serious consequences of not SO As as the patient had mental capacity as judged per protocol attached, their choice would be respected: If the patient is assessed as lacking mental capacity the GP would with the help of the family make a choice that was in the patient s best interest. Please refer to the copy of summary of Mental Capaeity Act and attached_ 3_ A full and proper documentation of the discussions that would take place between GP, the patient/patient' s family in these circumstances would be made in patient notes. Please refer to basic recording in the Mental Capacity Act 2005 Policy. Hama Medical Centre is the trading nanc 0l HMC (Kim berley) Limited Registered No; 8244108 This practice is a member of the Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group, group of local NHS practices; making local decisions for local people. NHS Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group They very they the doing long Policy

Hama Medical Centre 11 Nottingham Road, Kimberley, Nottingham NG16 2NB Telephone 0115 9382101 0115 9459208 Website: HWwhamamedicalccsuk We the steps outlined above meet with your satisfaction We will be very pleased to engage with yourself on any matter YOU feel is not addressed. Yours sincerely_ Flama Medical centre_ Hautna Medical Centre is trading name of HMC (Kimberley) Limited Registered No: 8244108 This practice is member of the Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group, group of local NHS practices, making local decisions [Or local people NHS Nottingham West Clinical Commissioning Group Fax hope the
Sent To
  • HAMA Medical Centre, NHS Commissioning Board Derbyshire and Nottinghamshire, Ministry of Justice
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 10 Feb 2014
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On 16tn October 2013, commenced an investigation into the death of Cynthia Fretwell; aged 84 The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on 12th November 2013. The conclusion of the inquest was: On the 12th of February 2013 Cynthia Fretwell died as a result of peritonitis as a result of an infected bladder which had not responded to treatment by antibiotics.
Circumstances of the Death
Mrs Fretwell had a history of abdominal pain and on 8" February 2013,she was admitted to the emergency department of the Queens Medical Centre in Nottingham. She had been diagnosed by her GP as having obstructive jaundice following a home visit: Upon admission Mrs Fretwell; was treated with antibiotics as the working diagnosis was of an inflamed bladder and localised peritonitis Mrs Fretwell s condition improved and she was discharged on 9h February 2013 to continue a course of antibiotics in the community_ On 1th February 2013, Mrs Fretwell's GP visited her at home as she was feeling unwell: It was noted that she was suffering from a temperature, tenderness in her gallbladder and jaundice. Mrs Fretwell was not admitted to hospital On 12.02.13 Mrs Fretwell's family contacted her GP again 2s Mrs Fretwell was still not well A telephone consultation took place but Fretwell was not seen in person by the GP. Mrs Fretwell remained at home and was not admitted into hospital. She died at 25pm that evening
Action Should Be Taken
In my opinion, action should be taken to prevent future deaths and believe you have the power to take such action.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Community mental health services for violence-fixated children
Southport Inquiry
Mental health access for alcohol addiction
Mental health assessment powers for isolated children
Southport Inquiry
Mental health access for alcohol addiction
Standardised Advance Care Planning
COVID-19 Inquiry
No person-centred care
Independent review of use of force on mentally ill detainees
Brook House Inquiry
Mental health access for alcohol addiction
Patient-focused correspondence
Paterson Inquiry
No person-centred care
Explaining independent sector differences
Paterson Inquiry
No person-centred care
Reflection period for consent
Paterson Inquiry
No person-centred care
Communicating complaint escalation
Paterson Inquiry
No person-centred care
Mandatory independent complaint resolution
Paterson Inquiry
No person-centred care
Age-Appropriate Hospital Settings
Hyponatraemia Inquiry
No person-centred care

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.