19
Rejected
The Department told us that it does not collect data on the suitability of facilities...
Conclusion
The Department told us that it does not collect data on the suitability of facilities in the same way that it does for the condition of the schools estate, and does not systematically collect information on capital projects aimed at improving educational outcomes, such as science labs. It explained that these facilities are taken into account by Ofsted when assessing a school’s performance, and we noted that a school’s rating will sometimes be 39 Committee of Public Accounts, Academy schools’ finances, Thirtieth Report of Session 2017–19, HC 760, 30 March 2018 40 HM Treasury, Treasury Minutes – Government response to the Committee of Public Accounts on the Twentieth to the Thirtieth reports from Session 2017–19, Cm 9618, May 2018 41 Academy schools sector in England: Consolidated Annual Report and Accounts for the year ended 31 August 2020, pages 24–25 42 Q78 43 Academy schools sector in England: Consolidated Annual Report and Accounts for the year ended 31 August 2020, page 93 44 Qq 98–98 45 Condition of School Building Survey: Key findings, May 2021, p.4 46 Q100; Department for Education Main Estimate 2021–22: Estimates memorandum, para 1.4 Academies Sector Annual Report and Accounts 2019/20 15 downgraded because it has small or old classrooms, for example.47 We had previously challenged the Department on the buildings data it collected, noting that in some instances there may be no issue with the condition of the school building but the conditions for learning may not be fit for purpose.48 We asked the Department how it considered whether it would get better educational outcomes as a result of the investment as part of schools’ bids for funding. It accepted that it had a better and more detailed understanding on the condition and funding for the maintenance of schools that are in poor condition than it did for the suitability of facilities. It explained that, while it considered suitability important, it was difficult to prioritise that over other concerns such a
Government Response Summary
The government explicitly disagrees with the recommendation (quoted in its response) to collect and publish data on pupils' access to and condition of learning facilities. It states it prioritizes ensuring sufficient school places and a safe, operational estate, and is rolling out Net Capacity Assessments for teaching space, but not the specific amenity data requested.
Government Response
Rejected
Government Response
Rejected
HM Government
Rejected
3: PAC conclusion: The Department still does not understand well enough the conditions of the school estate, meaning it does not know whether pupils have access to the learning facilities they need. 3: PAC recommendation: The Department should, within the next year, collect and publish data on pupils’ access to learning facilities, and the condition of such amenities, for example IT provision, science and technology labs, arts facilities and associated equipment. The Department should report how much capital investment is required to provide all pupils with access to such core facilities. 3.1 The government disagrees with the Committee’s recommendation. 3.2 The department has noted the Committee’s recommendation. The department recently piloted central delivery of Net Capacity Assessments (NCA), which assess the teaching space (size, type and use of rooms) in individual schools. It is developing plans to roll-out centralised delivery of NCA across secondary and special schools from 2023. As well as providing a more up-to-date and accurate picture of capacity, there will be opportunities to explore joining-up NCA and condition data to improve the department’s intelligence on the quality of provision across the estate. 3.3 All new buildings delivered by the department provide suitable accommodation built to high standards. The department recognises that the suitability of buildings can be a particular challenge for pupils with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND). £2.6 billion has been committed over the next three years to provide new places and make existing provision suitable and accessible for children and young people with SEND or who require alternative provision. 3.4 The department, however, continues to prioritise ensuring sufficient school places and that the estate remains in a safe, operational condition. That is why both departmental and local authority resources are focused on collecting essential data to support these priorities. In addition to collecting annual school capacity data, the department has significantly improved its understanding of the condition of the school estate, collecting consistent, comparable data through the Property Data Survey (2012-2014) and the Condition Data Collection (2017-19). The department has published summary findings from these surveys and shared detailed reports with schools and their responsible bodies. The Condition Data Collection 2 is collecting updated data through to 2026.
Source
Committee
Public Accounts Committee
Report
Forty-Seventh Report - Academies Sector Annual Report and Accounts 2019/20
25 Mar 2022
HC 994
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age
4.3 yrs
Report published
25 Mar 2022