14 Deferred

We asked the Bank whether it considered the Department’s questions about Greensill’s accreditation as the...

Conclusion
We asked the Bank whether it considered the Department’s questions about Greensill’s accreditation as the Department encouraging the approval of Greensill’s application. The Bank told us that it had considered the level of interest from the Department as “unusual”, but that it considered it “understandable that the Department in charge of looking after business would ask how various things were progressing”.37 It explained that it wanted to make sure that its processes had not been “interfered with” and while this was “unlikely”, it was something the Bank wanted to test.38 On 30 April 2021, the Bank launched an internal review to test if there had been any external influence that had impacted its decision to accredit Greensill, and whether its independence had been undermined. The Bank told us that the review had found no attempts to undermine the Bank’s independence and while the level of interest from the Department was “unusual”, it “was very confident that it did not have an impact” on its decision to accredit Greensill.39 The purpose of the review was to find out whether anyone attempted to exert influence over the Bank, not just whether any attempts were successful or not. The Bank told us the review concluded that there were not attempts to undermine its independence.40 Other parts of government Greensill applied to for support
Government Response Summary
The government states that its Shareholder Relationship Framework Document is being updated, and consideration will be given to changes regarding operational independence for 'Service Arm' activities, with a commitment to write to the Committee on the outcome.
Government Response
Deferred
HM Government Deferred
6.1 The government agrees with the Committee’s recommendation. Target implementation date: Spring 2022 6.2 The department is extremely mindful of the need to respect the Bank’s operational independence and will always seek to ensure any correspondence with the Bank reflects that, where it applies. 6.3 The Shareholder Relationship Framework Document governs the relationship between the Bank and the Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy’s (BEIS) Secretary of State, who is the sole shareholder, and informs how officials from the department and the Bank work together on a day-to-day basis. This document includes a specific undertaking (‘Operational Independence Undertaking’) which sets out the Bank’s independence in respect of operational or commercial matters, though it does not apply to activities undertaken by the Bank’s ‘Service Arm’, such as the COVID-19 programmes. ‘Service Arm’ activity is governed by a service agreement and matters of operational independence for programmes carried out by the ‘Service Arm’ are defined in relevant service agreement schedules. 6.4 The Shareholder Relationship Framework Document is currently being updated. As part of this process, consideration will be given to whether any changes are required on the matter of operational independence with respect to ‘Service Arm’ activity, including with respect to correspondence between the department and the Bank in relation to the delivery of such activity. The department will write to the Committee on the outcome of its considerations.
Addressee Bodies
HM Treasury
Timeline
Recommendation age 4.7 yrs
Report published 20 Nov 2021