First Report - The forgotten: how White working-class pupils have been let down, and how to change it

Select Committee
Education Committee HC 85 22 June 2021
Report Status Government responded
Conclusions & Recommendations 41 items (26 recs)
Government Response (AI assessment · 41 of 41 classified)
Government response
The forgotten: how White working-class pupils have been let down, and how to change it - Government response to the Committee’s First Report · published 4 Nov 2021

Recommendations & Conclusions

17 results
5 Recommendation Accepted
Schools should consider whether the promotion of politically controversial terminology, including White Privilege, is consistent...
Recommendation
Schools should consider whether the promotion of politically controversial terminology, including White Privilege, is consistent with their duties under the Equality Act 2010. The Department should take steps to ensure that young people are not inadvertently being inducted into political … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government confirms that schools must not promote partisan political views, including contested theories like 'white privilege,' as fact. It states it has already begun developing guidance for schools to help them teach complex political issues in a balanced, impartial, and age-appropriate way.
Department for Education
View Details
7 Conclusion Accepted
Para 44
Schools have an important role in how well disadvantaged White children recover from the pandemic.
Conclusion
Schools have an important role in how well disadvantaged White children recover from the pandemic. This relates to academic progress, emotional development, and good mental health. This is as true for disadvantaged White pupils as it is for other groups, … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government acknowledges the priority of mental health and wellbeing, detailing ongoing and committed initiatives such as the rollout of Mental Health Support Teams, senior mental health lead training, various funding streams, and an ambitious education recovery plan.
Department for Education
View Details
13 Recommendation Accepted
Para 69
The free school system has failed to place new schools in areas of highest need...
Recommendation
The free school system has failed to place new schools in areas of highest need and so has failed to reach left behind pupils, and should be encouraged in areas of disadvantage or deprivation.
Government Response Summary
The government strongly agrees that free schools are important for raising standards in disadvantaged communities. It highlights past and ongoing efforts to direct free schools to areas of high deprivation and commits to continuing to support and prioritise growth in areas of greatest need.
Department for Education
View Details
14 Recommendation Accepted
The Department must take a more proactive role in directing the evolution of free schools.
Recommendation
The Department must take a more proactive role in directing the evolution of free schools. It is not enough to suppose that disadvantaged White communities in left- behind areas will have the same resources as inner-city areas to create their … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states it already takes a proactive role in directing new free schools to areas of high deprivation, including those with underperforming White working-class pupils, and will continue to prioritise applications focused on raising attainment for disadvantaged pupils.
Department for Education
View Details
17 Conclusion Accepted
Para 87
High-quality, joined-up education and health support for disadvantaged White families in the early years of...
Conclusion
High-quality, joined-up education and health support for disadvantaged White families in the early years of their child’s life is crucial and has demonstrable benefits. The Family Hub model is ideally placed to deliver continuity of support and care, helping disadvantaged … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the importance of joined-up support via Family Hubs, committing over £500 million to the Start for Life offer, establishing a new cross-government unit, and providing funding for 75 areas to open or expand Family Hubs.
Department for Education
View Details
18 Recommendation Accepted
Para 88
However, there are areas of the country, including those serving disadvantaged White communities, where families...
Recommendation
However, there are areas of the country, including those serving disadvantaged White communities, where families do not have this support. The Government’s work on the National Centre, and investment of £14 million is positive, but children need this support now. Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the recommendation, committing over £500m to the Start for Life offer, establishing a new Start for Life Unit, and funding 75 areas to open or expand Family Hubs to provide accessible support services.
Department for Education
View Details
20 Recommendation Accepted
Para 90
All Family Hubs must have a clear strategy for the early years, with the aim...
Recommendation
All Family Hubs must have a clear strategy for the early years, with the aim of bringing services, including health visitors and early years educators, together into one place to make it easier for disadvantaged White families to navigate the … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts these recommendations, committing over £500m to the Start for Life offer, championing Family Hubs, and funding 75 areas to open or expand them. It also highlights the cross-government Start for Life Unit and the National Centre for Family Hubs which will explore a 'key contact' for families and support local authorities.
Department for Education
View Details
21 Conclusion Accepted
Para 100
We know that parents who are willing and able to engage with their children’s education...
Conclusion
We know that parents who are willing and able to engage with their children’s education have a positive influence on it. But we must not assume that all parents have the knowledge and skills to do so. We also know … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the underlying premise of the conclusion, stating it is investing over £500m in the Start for Life offer, championing Family Hubs, and funding 75 areas to establish or expand these hubs to provide joined-up support.
Department for Education
View Details
22 Recommendation Accepted
Para 101
Schools are well placed to be trusted institutions that can support and work with Family...
Recommendation
Schools are well placed to be trusted institutions that can support and work with Family Hubs to build strong relationships and help disadvantaged White parents 60 The forgotten: how White working-class pupils have been let down, and how to change … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government accepts the recommendation and states that the National Centre for Family Hubs will work with local authorities to help establish relationships with various community organisations, including schools, to ensure Family Hubs are well-integrated and accessible.
Department for Education
View Details
26 Conclusion Accepted
Para 109
Given the number of disadvantaged White pupils leaving education every year without a strong pass...
Conclusion
Given the number of disadvantaged White pupils leaving education every year without a strong pass in English and Maths GCSE, it seems that the impact of parental lack of confidence in learning will continue. Helping disadvantaged White parents with their … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government agrees on the importance of parental support and commits an additional £3.8 billion to further education and skills, including a new £560 million Multiply program for adult numeracy, to improve adult skills, including for disadvantaged White parents.
Department for Education
View Details
28 Conclusion Accepted
Para 115
Good teachers who understand disadvantaged White students’ needs and who can be good role models...
Conclusion
Good teachers who understand disadvantaged White students’ needs and who can be good role models are central to raising this group’s outcomes. We know that teaching quality is worse in disadvantaged areas than in wealthier areas, with schools less likely … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government highlights increased school funding and Pupil Premium, and new requirements for schools to use Pupil Premium on evidence-based approaches and publish spending rationale, demonstrating existing actions to support disadvantaged pupils.
Department for Education
View Details
30 Conclusion Accepted
Para 127
School funding has failed to keep pace with where deprivation is in the country, and...
Conclusion
School funding has failed to keep pace with where deprivation is in the country, and as a result schools serving disadvantaged communities, including disadvantaged White communities, have suffered financially. The National Funding Formula promises to correct this, but the formula’s … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government highlights significant increases in overall school funding and Pupil Premium, asserting that this constitutes the 'biggest funding boost for schools in a decade.' It also outlines amendments to Pupil Premium conditions to ensure evidence-based spending and transparency, addressing concerns about funding effectiveness.
Department for Education
View Details
31 Conclusion Accepted
Para 128
Additional funding for disadvantaged students, including disadvantaged White students, is welcome, but is insufficient and...
Conclusion
Additional funding for disadvantaged students, including disadvantaged White students, is welcome, but is insufficient and insufficiently targeted and does not always reflect true level of need. This seems to have extended to the Government’s “catch-up” funding, with insufficiently targeted formulas … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government highlights significant increases in overall school funding and Pupil Premium, asserting that this addresses concerns about funding levels. It also outlines amendments to Pupil Premium conditions to require evidence-based spending and transparency, aiming to improve targeting and effectiveness.
Department for Education
View Details
34 Conclusion Accepted
Para 132
We support the Department’s insistence that all children should benefit from an ambitious and challenging...
Conclusion
We support the Department’s insistence that all children should benefit from an ambitious and challenging curriculum. A culture of low expectations is damaging for White working-class children. However, too many disadvantaged White pupils are leaving school without essential qualifications, and … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government reiterates its existing policy that all state-funded schools must offer a knowledge-rich curriculum, asserting that this approach raises standards and benefits disadvantaged pupils by providing essential knowledge, rather than proposing new changes.
Department for Education
View Details
36 Recommendation Accepted
Para 144
Level 2 apprenticeships are a vital stepping-stone for disadvantaged learners.
Recommendation
Level 2 apprenticeships are a vital stepping-stone for disadvantaged learners. The Department must investigate and address the falling numbers of apprenticeship starts from deprived communities, to ensure disadvantaged White pupils have equal access to the opportunities offered by skills-based routes. … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government agrees on the importance of apprenticeships and states it monitors participation from deprived communities. It highlights existing support for SMEs, progression routes, £7 million for flexi-job apprenticeships, and £1,000 payments for young apprentices, but does not commit to rebalancing the levy or introducing skills tax credits.
Department for Education
View Details
39 Conclusion Accepted
Para 152
Accessing higher education is the “end of the funnel” for many pupils’ academic journeys.
Conclusion
Accessing higher education is the “end of the funnel” for many pupils’ academic journeys. Evidence suggests that for disadvantaged White pupils the funnel narrows dramatically on leaving school. These statistics represent the outcome of accumulated educational disadvantage starting in early … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government agrees on the importance of social mobility for White working-class students and confirms it has already directed the OfS to focus on this group in its strategic priorities, including strengthening guidance to providers on increasing access.
Department for Education
View Details
41 Recommendation Accepted
The OfS should also commit to a report to Parliament in a year’s time to...
Recommendation
The OfS should also commit to a report to Parliament in a year’s time to review progress against this measure and their targets and the Secretary of State’s request for a focus on disadvantaged White boys accessing higher education. The … Read more
Government Response Summary
The government states the OfS already produces annual reports and monitors demographic trends. It confirms the OfS keeps its definition of 'under-represented groups' under review and will deploy its new ABCs measure to enable closer targeting of White working-class students.
Department for Education
View Details