Jodie McCann

PFD Report All Responded Ref: 2023-0131
Date of Report 20 April 2023
Coroner Elizabeth Didcock
Coroner Area Nottinghamshire
Response Deadline est. 15 June 2023
All 1 response received · Deadline: 15 Jun 2023
Coroner's Concerns (AI summary)
Lack of comprehensive airway strategies, non-adherence to national algorithms/checklists, and inadequate daily checking of difficult airway equipment increase patient risk. Failures in mortality review also delayed crucial organizational learning.
View full coroner's concerns
 There is limited evidence to date for the introduction and continuing use of comprehensive airway strategies, with structured planning and preparation, when a difficult airway is anticipated. There should be airway plans A, B, and C recorded, shared, and the equipment and skills to carry them out must be available  There is limited evidence to date for the universal use of the NAP4 algorithms and checklists, which should be available on the difficult airway trolley, and be familiar to all ICU nursing and medical staff, and to the wider anaesthetic team  There is limited evidence to date, for the robust daily checking of all necessary equipment on the difficult airway trolley, to ensure immediate replacement of all key equipment if it is broken or misplaced  The Mortality Review policy was not followed, leading to a significant delay in completing the serious incident review, delaying Trust learning, and delaying the family’s understanding of the circumstances of Jodie’s death. There is limited evidence of progress in implementing the national Patient Safety Incident Response Framework at the Trust I am not reassured that necessary actions to address these serious issues identified are in place.
Responses
University Hospitals of Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust NHS / Health Body
9 Jun 2023
Action Taken
The Intensive Care Unit at Queens Hospital Burton introduced a Critical Care Airway Plan, anaesthetic consultants provided airway management training, and an updated Incident Reporting Policy will include presentations and discussions at Trust learning forums; the Trust is also implementing the Patient Safety Incident Response Framework. (AI summary)
View full response
Dear Madam

I am writing in response to the Regulation 28 Report dated 28 April 2023, following the Inquest relating to Ms McCann's death. As a Trust we fully accept that there were significant and serious issues in the care provided to Ms McCann. We have apologised to Ms McCann's family for these failings and taken this Notice with the seriousness that they and yourself would rightly expect. We know that investigating incidents that have led, or could lead to harm is a vitally important feature of safe organisations. UHDB is committed to continued openness and transparency, and to making sure that we investigate, communicate and learn when things go wrong so that we can embed improvements that can support safer care. Enclosed you will find commentary that details the robust actions taken as a result of the learning from Ms McCann's sad case, as well as details of future planned work around our mortality governance processes, for assurance. The Trust has also retained 360 Assurance to audit the actions taken following this incident. Should you require any additional information please do not hesitate to contact me.
Sent To
  • Derby and Burton NHS Foundation Trust
Response Status
Linked responses 1 of 1
56-Day Deadline 15 Jun 2023
All responses received
About PFD responses

Organisations named in PFD reports must respond within 56 days explaining what actions they are taking.

Source: Courts and Tribunals Judiciary

Report Sections
Investigation and Inquest
On the 2nd April 2022, I commenced an investigation into the death of Jodie Catherine McCann. The investigation concluded at the end of the inquest on the 19th April 2023 The conclusion of the inquest was a Narrative as follows: Jodie died on the 2nd April 2022 at Queens Hospital, Burton-on-Trent, following a prolonged cardiac arrest, caused by a lack of oxygen, as the trachea could not be re-intubated following the sudden displacement of her tracheostomy tube. Jodie required the tracheostomy tube to provide ventilation to her lungs, as she had developed multi organ failure following an earlier cardiac arrest of at least 17 minutes at Kings Mill Hospital on 18.3.22. This first arrest at Kings Mill Hospital was sudden and unpredictable, likely caused by airway obstruction, from a combination of opiates affecting her breathing, her high BMI, and the pain and stress of gallstone pancreatitis which required strong opiate medication. Undertreated Hypothyroidism also likely made a more than minimal contribution to this first arrest. Jodie was making a reasonable recovery from the first arrest, with improving neurology and reducing ventilatory requirements. She was transferred to Burton Hospital on 22.3.22 for further critical care management. There she continued to improve, but required continuing ventilation. A tracheostomy tube to aid weaning from ventilation was inserted on 31.3.22. There was no individualised planning for the possibility of tracheostomy displacement , which was a known risk, with no plan to ensure the correct equipment was available, and no plan to ensure senior help was available as quickly as possible, should the tracheostomy tube become displaced. These serious issues of care at Burton Hospital, on a balance of probability, made a more than minimal contribution to Jodie’s death.
Circumstances of the Death
Jodie was a previously fit and well young woman aged twenty two. She developed gallstone pancreatitis requiring admission to Kings Mill Hospital on 16.3.22. She had a cardiac arrest on the ward at KMH on 18.3.22, and as a consequence developed multi organ failure, requiring Critical Care treatment. She had a period of care at KMH CCU, but had to be transferred to Burton Hospital on 22.3.22 as KMH CCU was at operational capacity.

She continued to make good progress on the CCU at Burton Hospital, but there were continuing issues of difficult airway management. Jodie had a tracheostomy tube placed on 31.3.22, which became displaced early morning on 2.4.22. This could not be replaced, nor another airway achieved. She died from a further prolonged cardiac arrest as a consequence of this final hypoxic event. The Determination dated 19.4.23 gives detailed findings as to the circumstances of Jodie’s death, and is appended to this report.
Copies Sent To
2. Sherwood Forest Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust 3. , Consultant in Critical Care Medicine and Anaesthesia, UHDBT
Inquest Conclusion
Jodie died on the 2nd April 2022 at Queens Hospital, Burton-on-Trent, following a prolonged cardiac arrest, caused by a lack of oxygen, as the trachea could not be re-intubated following the sudden displacement of her tracheostomy tube. Jodie required the tracheostomy tube to provide ventilation to her lungs, as she had developed multi organ failure following an earlier cardiac arrest of at least 17 minutes at Kings Mill Hospital on 18.3.22. This first arrest at Kings Mill Hospital was sudden and unpredictable, likely caused by airway obstruction, from a combination of opiates affecting her breathing, her high BMI, and the pain and stress of gallstone pancreatitis which required strong opiate medication. Undertreated Hypothyroidism also likely made a more than minimal contribution to this first arrest. Jodie was making a reasonable recovery from the first arrest, with improving neurology and reducing ventilatory requirements. She was transferred to Burton Hospital on 22.3.22 for further critical care management. There she continued to improve, but required continuing ventilation. A tracheostomy tube to aid weaning from ventilation was inserted on 31.3.22. There was no individualised planning for the possibility of tracheostomy displacement , which was a known risk, with no plan to ensure the correct equipment was available, and no plan to ensure senior help was available as quickly as possible, should the tracheostomy tube become displaced. These serious issues of care at Burton Hospital, on a balance of probability, made a more than minimal contribution to Jodie’s death.
Related Inquiry Recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations addressing similar themes

Uniform policy for obtaining technical advice
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Major project lessons learned
Streamlining NHS construction quality procedures
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Major project lessons learned
Information on common construction errors
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Major project lessons learned
Independent validation of hospital construction
Scottish Hospitals Inquiry
Major project lessons learned
Police-ambulance terminology interoperability
Southport Inquiry
Emergency responder equipment training
Ambulance staff training exercise funding
Southport Inquiry
Emergency responder equipment training
Triennial Parliamentary Resilience Reports
COVID-19 Inquiry
Emergency responder equipment training
Clarify whether HCRS and OCS assessment processes differ
Post Office Horizon Inquiry
Major project lessons learned
Statutory Child Rights Impact Assessments
COVID-19 Inquiry
Emergency responder equipment training
Fit-Testing Preparedness
COVID-19 Inquiry
Emergency responder equipment training

Data sourced from Courts and Tribunals Judiciary under the Open Government Licence.