Inquiries / Themes / Mental health and suicide prevention

Restraint and restrictive practice in health and care

Physical, chemical and mechanical restraint, seclusion, long-term segregation in hospitals and care. Not: police (see police restraint, use of force and Taser); prison segregation units (see segregation and separation).

22 inquiry recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations

What public inquiries recommended · 22 recommendations

2026

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R37
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

Education and training on the use of restrictive practices should be grounded in human rights principles and the dedicated human rights specialist appointed in accordance with Recommendation 21 (R21) should work with staff on this approach.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R36
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

Use of seclusion should be considered an extraordinary and exceptional intervention. Each intervention should be subject to a serious event audit, conducted by a professional outside the service provider’s learning disabilities services. This audit should be shared with the person’s next of kin and the RQIA.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R35
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

Given the elevated risk of inappropriate use of restrictive practices with individuals with learning disabilities and/or autistic people, BHSCT and all HSCTs should automatically place any inpatient facility or facility for people with challenging behaviour on its risk register.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R34
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

All HSCTs should develop two clear operational debriefing policies. The first should apply to both staff and people with learning disabilities and autistic people who are involved in, or affected by, aggressive behaviour. A separate debriefing after any restraint or seclusion incident should also be developed. This…

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R32
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

HSCTs should implement a comprehensive set of balanced performance measures across all services for people with learning disabilities, including those commissioned from third-party providers. These measures should include: Trends in the use of restrictive practices; Trends of aggressive behaviour incidents, including…

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R31
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Northern Ireland Executive and Northern Ireland Practice and Education Council

The effectiveness of the education programme for staff in relation to restraint reduction should be measured through defined data metrics. This is to ensure that every instance of restraint is clearly justified and appropriately utilised.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R30
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

HSCTs should appoint a non-executive director (NED) to act as a champion for restraint reduction, with a mandate to hold executive directors accountable for delivery.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R29
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

All facilities providing residential services for people with learning disabilities and autistic people should provide sufficient psychology input for each patient, to obviate the need for restrictive practices in all but the most exceptional circumstances.

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R28
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

The Restraint Reduction Network identifies six principles to avoid the use of restrictive practice. While there is evidence that some Trusts have adopted these principles, further action is needed to ensure the principles are fully embedded. These principles must be embedded in policies and practices. The principles…

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R14
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

Observation records detailing all use of restraint and seclusion should be completed by the individual observing. In HSCT facilities, if the observer is unregistered, a registered staff member should countersign the entry rather than create a second-hand record. In private and 3rd sector facilities the individual in…

Muckamore Abbey Hospital Inquiry Recommendation R8
18 Jun 2026
Addressed to Health and Social Care Northern Ireland and Northern Ireland Executive

Medication should never be used simply to subdue people in the absence of other forms of treatment and good quality care. DoH should issue a regional audit pro forma to measure compliance with National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) guidelines and Trusts should conduct quarterly audits. These audits…

2023

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 19
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office must ensure that guidance is issued to healthcare staff in immigration removal centres clarifying their role in use of force incidents. It must liaise as necessary with NHS England and any relevant medical regulators. The Home Office must ensure that mandatory training is introduced for healthcare…

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 16
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office must urgently commission an independent review (with the power to make recommendations) of use of force on detained people with mental ill health within immigration removal centres. The review must consider: how, when and whether to use force on detained people with mental ill health (including the…

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 15
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office must introduce, as a matter of urgency, a new and comprehensive detention services order to address use of force in immigration removal centres. The detention services order must include the following issues: the permissible justifications for the use of force within immigration removal centres, based…

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 14
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office and contractors operating immigration removal centres must ensure that all staff are aware that the technique of handcuffing detained people with their hands behind their back while seated is not permitted, given its association with positional asphyxia.

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 13
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office must regularly (and at least quarterly) audit the use of Rule 40 and Rule 42 across the immigration detention estate, in order to identify trends, any training needs and required improvements. In addition, HM Inspectorate of Prisons and the National Chair and Management Board of Independent Monitoring…

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 12
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office and contractors operating immigration removal centres must provide regular training, at least annually, on the operation of Rule 40 and Rule 42 of the Detention Centre Rules 2001, which must include: that Rules 40 and 42 are the only powers under which detained people in immigration removal centres can…

Brook House Inquiry Recommendation 10
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Home Office

The Home Office must amend, as a matter of urgency, Detention Services Order 02/2017: Removal from Association (Detention Centre Rule 40) and Temporary Confinement (Detention Centre Rule 42) and, if necessary, the Detention Services Operating Standards Manual for Immigration Service Removal Centres, to clarify who can…

2022

Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse Recommendation FR-5
20 Oct 2022
Addressed to UK Government

The Inquiry recommends (as originally stated in its Sexual Abuse of Children in Custodial Institutions: 2009-2017 Investigation Report, dated February 2019) that the UK government prohibits the use of any technique that deliberately induces pain (previously referred to by the Inquiry as 'pain compliance techniques')…

2019

Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse Recommendation 17
28 Feb 2019
Addressed to Ministry of Justice

The Chair and Panel consider that the use of pain compliance techniques should be seen as a form of child abuse, and that it is likely to contribute to a culture of violence, which may increase the risk of child sexual abuse. The Chair and Panel recommend that the Ministry of Justice prohibits the use of pain…

2011

Baha Mousa Inquiry Recommendation BAHA-4
8 Sep 2011
Addressed to Ministry of Defence

The essence of guidance on hooding should be that it is prohibited at any time for whatever purpose to place a sandbag or other cover over a CPERS’ head.

2000

North Wales Child Abuse Tribunal Recommendation WATE-(28)
15 Feb 2000

Central government should take the initiative to promote and validate training in safe methods of restraint with a view to making such training readily available for residential child care staff and foster parents.

Every record on this page is an inquiry recommendation published by the inquiry named on its card, and each card links to the recommendation. The themes, and which recommendations sit under each, are our own classification.

Licensing and attribution for every source