2022

PFD Reports
Reports: 385 Areas: 67

78% response rate (above 63% average).

Clear 262 results
Emma Simkin
All Responded
2022-0313 12 Oct 2022 Lincolnshire
Vine Street Surgery and LPFT Legal Serv…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Professionals are perceived to accept patients' statements at face value, failing to detect "masking" of mental illness and often ignoring family concerns, requiring policy and training review.
Action Planned (AI summary) Lincolnshire County Council intends to review its AMHP policies to incorporate references to 'masking' and will discuss the coroner's concerns at the next AMHP Forum.
Charles Stringer
All Responded
2022-0317 10 Oct 2022 Surrey
Surrey County Council, Highways Agency …
Concerns summary (AI summary) The council demonstrated a lack of reflection and action on pothole management, with insufficient information for inspectors, mechanistic risk assessments, poor communication, and slow repairs.
Action Taken (AI summary) Surrey County Council has reinforced the process for Surrey Police and the Surrey Contact Centre to notify the Highways Service immediately in the event of serious injuries or deaths related to road defects, and instructed Customer Care Centre operatives to make direct contact with Highways if there are any uncertainties.
Charles Rothwell
All Responded
2022-0312 5 Oct 2022 Cheshire
Department of Health and Social Care, N…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Ambulance service demand critically outstrips supply, leading to excessively long response times across all categories due to wider resource shortages in healthcare and social care.
Noted (AI summary) AACE acknowledges the coroner's concerns about ambulance response times and capacity and highlights that the issue has been flagged nationally, leading to a national demand and capacity modelling exercise led by NHSE.
Reginald Cauthery
All Responded
2022-0326 4 Oct 2022 Inner North London
CECOPS Care Quality Commission Department of Health and Social Care +3 more
Concerns summary (AI summary) A vulnerable person's telecare service was not reviewed despite increased fire risk, and smoke alarms were not connected to telecare, delaying emergency fire brigade notification.
Noted (AI summary) The TEC Services Association (TSA) will issue guidance to certified monitoring organizations by the end of November 2022. They also plan to develop a Fire Call Handling Pathway Decision Support Tool with the support of NFCC and LFB, but anticipate it will not be available until 2024. The CQC acknowledges the concerns but states they relate to services outside their scope of regulation (fire service and telecare service) and therefore they have no powers to prevent future deaths in relation to these services. The Department of Health and Social Care has reminded local authorities to consider technology-enabled care in maintaining independence and linking preventative devices like smoke detectors. It also published an updated Adult Social Care Digital Skills Framework to support the development of digital skills across the adult social care workforce. The Home Office will share information from the case with the National Fire Chiefs Council (NFCC) and encourage them to disseminate findings and highlight the importance of linking telecare systems to smoke alarms during fire safety checks. The organisation recommends monitored smoke detectors and rapid heat detectors for elderly and vulnerable service users, referencing recommendations made with London Fire Brigade in 2003. The London Borough of Hackney will address its procedures and guidance within its 'Mosaic' system to reduce risks to vulnerable individuals, especially regarding fire safety for those with risk factors like being bed-bound and a smoker; a table detailing planned actions and timelines is attached.
George Elliott
All Responded
2022-0309 4 Oct 2022 Avon
North Bristol NHS Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) The patient safety investigation overlooked obvious failings in falls risk assessment and management, including inadequate assessment and missed re-assessments, resulting in lost learning opportunities and compromised patient safety.
Action Taken (AI summary) The Trust acknowledges shortcomings in the investigation report regarding Mr. Elliot's fall and states that the Falls Policy referenced has been replaced with an updated policy in December 2021. They are conducting a gap analysis using the PSIRF national guidance to improve investigation processes, and findings will be reported through relevant committees.
Katherine Tyrer
All Responded
2022-0307 30 Sep 2022 Liverpool and Wirral
Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Fou…
Concerns summary (AI summary) The ward's inadequate layout hindered patient observation. Inexperienced staff, lacking clear protocols for senior review, conducted inadequate risk assessments, leaving vulnerable patients unattended after trigger events.
Action Taken (AI summary) Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Foundation Trust updated its Supportive Observation & Engagement Policy (CP25) to include a requirement for an automatic review when a non-registered member of staff identifies a trigger event. In addition, face-to-face clinical risk training using a formulation approach will be delivered to all in-patient staff as part of a Quality Improvement approach.
Shahan Aman
All Responded
2022-0306 30 Sep 2022 East London
Department of Health and Social Care Royal London Hospital
Concerns summary (AI summary) Miscommunications among nursing and medical staff, coupled with a discharging doctor's failure to check recent observations, led to a patient's concerns being overlooked before an inappropriate discharge.
Action Planned (AI summary) Barts Health NHS Trust is working through process pathway redesign to reduce pressure in emergency departments and reduce levels of risk. The trust also plans to work alongside North East London to support paediatric flow from the Emergency Department, exploring ambulatory step down from the paediatric ward and increased use of paediatric clinical decision unit to work into the community to support early discharge. Barts Health Trust has updated guidance on managing gastroenteritis in children and revised the Emergency Department's policy on observations prior to discharge, and is prompting clinicians to consider adding urine output assessment to the online patient documentation system; learning summaries from the incident will be shared trust-wide.
Charlotte Warkcup
All Responded
2022-0301 29 Sep 2022 Sunderland
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary (AI summary) Concerns exist regarding the safety of standalone midwife-led birthing centres, the lack of midwife recruitment for continuity of care, and insufficient detection of small gestational age babies.
Action Planned (AI summary) Version 3 of the Saving Babies’ Lives Care Bundle is being developed for publication in 2023, aiming to introduce a more nuanced risk assessment and clarify guidance for staff.
Aaron Edwards
All Responded
2022-0302 27 Sep 2022 South Wales Central
Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council
Concerns summary (AI summary) A dangerous road junction with poor visibility, exacerbated by school traffic, requires safety improvements to prevent further deaths from high-speed driving.
Action Planned (AI summary) Merthyr Tydfil Council disputes the coroner's concern about visibility at the junction. However, they state that planned road layout changes as part of the Welsh Governments A465 dualling project will remove the bridge/parapet obstruction, and the Gurnos Ring Road will become 20mph in September 2023.
Liam Lyes-Watson
All Responded
2022-0297 27 Sep 2022 Shropshire Telford and Wrekin
Midlands Partnership NHS Foundation tru…
Concerns summary (AI summary) The report identifies that a call handler was not trained and needed advice from a colleague who did not speak to the caller, and consideration should be given to recording incoming calls to the Access Team.
Action Taken (AI summary) The call handler has discussed their working practice in supervision meetings, an aide memoire has been introduced to gather relevant information when patients call to self-refer, and a mandatory question has been added to the RiO electronic patient record to ensure all staff ask about the caller's ethnicity.
Lewis Begley
All Responded
2022-0380 26 Sep 2022 Norfolk
Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) The mental health hospital lacked a proper record of stored medication, especially drugs subject to misuse, and had no system to track patient access or provide fixed overdose treatment training for doctors.
Action Planned (AI summary) Norfolk and Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust is revising its Medicines Management Policy, led by a new Chief Pharmacist, to address stock oversight. They will not train medics to administer Naloxone due to infrequent use.
Sandra Kirk
All Responded
2022-0298 26 Sep 2022 Surrey
NHS England NHS Improvement
Concerns summary (AI summary) Ligature risk policies inadequately address potential ligature items like clothing, focusing instead on anchor points and avoiding 'blanket restrictions' without sufficiently identifying actual risks to vulnerable patients.
Action Planned (AI summary) NHS England is reviewing national guidance around risk assessments and working towards a more personalised safety planning approach. They are supporting units in urgent need of support, redesigning the model of care, and driving cultural change through leadership development. NHS England acknowledges the concerns regarding ligature risk reduction policies and guidance. They state that Cygnet is providing ligature training and enhancing their ligature risk reduction policy. They are also reviewing national guidance around risk assessments.
Zachariah Richardson
All Responded
2022-0296 26 Sep 2022 Norfolk
Lincs Firwood Co Ltd and DD Dodds and S…
Concerns summary (AI summary) An inexperienced worker was left unsupervised with poorly maintained Fork Lift Trucks lacking critical safety devices. The company demonstrated a profound lack of health and safety understanding and failed to implement changes years after the death.
Action Taken (AI summary) DAC Beachcroft, on behalf of Lincs Firewood Company, states that the procedures were either already in place at the time of the incident, or have been enhanced since. Training includes task-specific chainsaw maintenance, emergency first aid, and health and safety modules.
Robert Howell
All Responded
2022-0294 26 Sep 2022 East Riding and Hull
Elm Tree Court Care Home and HICA Group
Concerns summary (AI summary) Critical care information and risk needs were not effectively communicated from team leaders to direct care staff, and care plans were inaccessible, leading to a lack of understanding of resident needs and falls policies.
Action Taken (AI summary) HICA has introduced a standard handover template and attendance sheet into all services and implemented electronic care planning. They are rolling out the iSTUMBLE platform to support staff on falls procedures and introducing weekly service falls meetings.
Nargis Begum
All Responded
2025-0287 16 Sep 2022 South Yorkshire East
Highways England
Concerns summary (AI summary) The public lacks crucial understanding and awareness regarding their responsibility to report motorway incidents, despite existing SMART motorway campaigns, leaving stationary vehicles a significant hazard.
Noted (AI summary) National Highways expresses sympathy and highlights existing measures to improve safety, including public awareness campaigns and the Smart Motorway Safety Evidence Stocktake and Action Plan. They urge road users to inform themselves about emergency procedures and who to contact.
Harper Denton
All Responded
2022-0288 15 Sep 2022 Bedfordshire and Luton
Metropolitan Police, College of Policin…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Police forces failed to adopt guidance for managing violent offenders and lacked proactive information sharing to protect children. Additionally, a national register for child cruelty offenders is missing, and health visitor safeguarding assessments are not mandatory.
Action Planned (AI summary) The College of Policing will update APP (Authorised Professional Practice) within three months to clarify that disclosure of information about a person who poses a risk of harm can be made to parents and/or carers of children. The MPS is reviewing its MAPPA processes, including scoping the feasibility of introducing a Potentially Dangerous Person (PDP) process as outlined by the College of Policing’s APP Guidance; the outcome of this review is anticipated within six months. The Home Office is considering options for better management of domestic abuse offenders, including a domestic abuse 'register', and is working to improve information and data sharing between agencies for safeguarding children, with a report due before Parliament in Summer 2023. The Department is updating resources for health visitors and school nurses, emphasizing assessments of family relationships and chronology of events for children with additional needs, due to be published shortly. They have also agreed to a cross-government programme of work focusing on strengthening whole family approaches and improving evidence.
Diane Austin-Martin
All Responded
2022-0286 14 Sep 2022 Manchester South
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary (AI summary) The report identifies a lack of mechanisms to ensure Social Services were aware of a vulnerable person's move, to ensure private care arrangements are of sufficient quality, and to maintain contact with agencies after initial claims and visits.
Noted (AI summary) The Department outlines duties and policies in Northern Ireland regarding support for vulnerable individuals moving locations and clarifies that NHS England has processes in place for managing newly registered patients, including initial assessments and referrals, noting that a consultation with Ms. Austin-Martin occurred shortly after registration.
Maureen Harrop
All Responded
2022-0285 14 Sep 2022 Manchester South
NHS England
Concerns summary (AI summary) Prolonged waits in the Emergency Department due to bed shortages and delays in essential surgery due to theatre capacity severely impacted the patient's physiological reserves and overall outcome.
Action Taken (AI summary) Tameside and Glossop ICFT has implemented a fractured neck of femur improvement programme, monitors compliance daily via the Divisional senior leadership team, and submits data to the National Hip Fracture Database, which specifically looks at care for patients over the age of 60, who undergo surgery following a hip fracture.
Irene Davies
All Responded
2022-0284 14 Sep 2022 Manchester South
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary (AI summary) Extended surgery wait times due to COVID backlogs and severe ambulance availability issues led to significant delays in critical care, causing distress and impacting patient outcomes.
Action Planned (AI summary) The NHS is implementing several measures to address elective surgery waiting times and ambulance handover delays, including expanding the use of surgical hubs, increasing bed capacity, and establishing 24/7 System Control Centres to better manage demand. The NHS will also expand falls response services right across the country.
Lilian Shearing
All Responded
2022-0283 14 Sep 2022 Lincolnshire
Tanglewood Cloverleaf Care Home
Concerns summary (AI summary) Despite known poor fluid intake, no risk assessment was conducted, and fluid charts were incomplete. The care home lacked adequate policies for assessing and managing fluid and nutritional intake.
Action Taken (AI summary) Tanglewood Cloverleaf Care Home has enhanced monitoring and auditing processes, introduced a new e-learning platform, focused on nutrition and hydration training, employed a care plan manager, and amended the Nutrition & Hydration policy to include current practice of monitoring and recording all intake.
Daniel Nelson
All Responded
2022-0282 12 Sep 2022 Lancashire with Blackburn and Darwen
Greater Manchester Mental Health NHS Fo…
Concerns summary (AI summary) The Trust lacked essential protocols, policies, or adequate standard operating procedures for governing Section 117 discharges, indicating a significant systemic gap in patient management.
Action Taken (AI summary) The Trust has developed a Section 117 Aftercare Policy, updated training for staff on Section 117 responsibilities, and updated their clinical record system to automatically flag patients eligible for aftercare. They will also hold a learning event on safe discharge and 117 responsibilities.
Delina Etienne
All Responded
2022-0279 12 Sep 2022 East London
Department of Health and Social Care East London NHS Foundation Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) The report identifies a chaotic response to a cardiac arrest, failure to escalate episodes of raised blood pressure, lack of venous thromboembolism (VTE) risk assessment, and a failure to admit that the patient had a DNACPR in place.
Action Taken (AI summary) East London NHS Foundation Trust has facilitated physical health simulations training across inpatient units and is undertaking them at least monthly in all units, with weekly ward managers meetings to plan simulation exercises; the electronic recording system for NEWS2 now has automatic alerts for all physical health observations recorded which are outside expected limits. East London NHS Foundation Trust has implemented an action plan that includes medical simulation training, Life Support training, and training on the correct escalation of patients with chest pain, and the electronic recording system for NEWS2 now has automatic alerts for all physical health observations recorded which are outside expected limits; a monthly audit of the ward in relation to resuscitation status record-keeping is underway, with CPR status now a formal part of the handover for each nursing shift.
Robert Taylor
All Responded
2022-0281 8 Sep 2022 Hampshire, Portsmouth and Southampton
University Hospital Southampton NHS Fou…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Emergency department and trauma staff lacked widespread awareness of checking the back of the throat in patients with epistaxis or facial fractures, potentially missing continued bleeding.
Action Taken (AI summary) Specific guidance to check the oropharynx in patients with epistaxis and facial trauma has been added to the surgical SHO induction sessions. The case was discussed at the ENT M&M meeting and it was agreed to raise awareness of epistaxis in facial trauma in OMFS and ED teams managing them.
Michael Rolfe
All Responded
2022-0280 7 Sep 2022 Lincolnshire
United Lincolnshire Hospital
Concerns summary (AI summary) A patient with liver and renal impairment was inappropriately prescribed Rivaroxaban, a contraindicated anticoagulant, significantly increasing bleeding risk and contributing to rectal bleeding and cerebral haemorrhage.
Noted (AI summary) The surgery provided a factual account of the patient's consultations and treatment based on medical records, noting the author was not involved in the patient's care and is no longer at the practice.
Frances Ollis
All Responded
2022-0276 6 Sep 2022 Plymouth, Torbay and South Devon
Devon NHS Integrated Care Commission
Concerns summary (AI summary) There was a missed opportunity to provide timely care and treatment to the deceased before she was found in extremis.
Action Planned (AI summary) NHS Devon ICB has asked commissioned services to review and update safeguarding policies, disseminated a learning brief to healthcare providers, and will present the learning from this case to safeguarding adult partnerships.