2023

PFD Reports
Reports: 552 Areas: 65

85% response rate (above 63% average).

552 results
Michael Sullivan
All Responded
2023-0200 20 Jun 2023 Manchester South
Stockport Integrated Care Partnership
Concerns summary (AI summary) Delays between GP referrals and Crisis Review Team assessments for vulnerable mental health patients highlight unclear processes regarding GP understanding, CRT prioritization, or triage effectiveness, causing patients to become seriously unwell before assessment.
Action Planned (AI summary) NHS Greater Manchester Integrated Care will present learning from this case to the Greater Manchester System Quality Group on 21st September 2023. Shared learning from this and similar cases will be cascaded to professionals through relevant governance and learning forums.
Joan Corcoran
All Responded
2023-0197 20 Jun 2023 Manchester South
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary (AI summary) Widespread, significant ambulance response delays for Category 2 calls, drastically exceeding target times, are caused by multifactorial issues including high demand and prolonged A&E handover times, directly contributing to patient deterioration and death.
Noted (AI summary) The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges concerns about ambulance response times. The response references the 'Delivery plan for recovering urgent and emergency care services' and notes improvements in ambulance response times and handover delays but acknowledges more work is needed.
Vaughan Whalley
All Responded
2023-0366 16 Jun 2023 Manchester North
Midlands Partnership NHS Foundation Tru…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Deficient suicide and self-harm risk assessments upon release from detention, coupled with poor communication to police and inadequate practitioner-detainee interaction, compromised effective risk management. A manager's review also lacked critical analysis or learning identification.
Action Planned (AI summary) Midlands Partnership University NHS Foundation Trust will deliver suicide prevention training to staff on 19th September 2023. They have written to the Chief Constable of West Mercia to propose joint investigations of suspected self-harm deaths relating to individuals who have been in custody to support shared learning.
Christine Cumbers
All Responded
2023-0196 16 Jun 2023 Essex
Clacton Community Practices
Concerns summary (AI summary) The GP practice failed to implement identified learnings from its Significant Event Analysis report, and lacked plans or timescales for addressing recognised shortcomings, risking future reoccurrences.
Action Taken (AI summary) Ranworth Medical Group addressed the consultation concern with the individual clinician and disseminated learning at a practice meeting on 9/8/22 in an anonymous manner. They completed an audit of consultations on 31/7/23 against a known criteria (NHSE audit XL template).
Girmaye Guyo
Partially Responded
2023-0195 16 Jun 2023 Manchester City
Department of Health and Social Care Ministry of Justice
Concerns summary (AI summary) There's a risk of patients being discharged under the Nearest Relative Power despite still meeting detention criteria, due to a lack of clear procedures and legal tests for clinicians to apply.
Noted (AI summary) The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges concerns regarding the use of Nearest Relative powers under the Mental Health Act. The response notes the Responsible Clinician's powers to bar requests for discharge and states the government does not intend to amend the Nearest Relative powers.
Nicholas Stout
All Responded
2023-0300 15 Jun 2023 County Durham and Darlington
Tees, Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundati…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Mental health crisis assessments are often delayed, essential Triage Tools and Safety Plans are not consistently completed, and safeguarding referrals for children are frequently missed.
Action Taken (AI summary) The Trust has implemented actions including updated risk assessment tools, safety plans, and a new Caseload Management Supervision Policy to support staff and improve patient safety. Tees Esk & Wear Valley NHS Foundation Trust has implemented and embedded several actions following this incident. These include improving timely assessment and treatment for people experiencing a mental health crisis, Quality Assurance audits of safety summaries and safety plans, and a new Caseload Management Supervision Policy.
Raquel Harper
Historic (No Identified Response)
2023-0192 13 Jun 2023 East London
Barts Health NHS Foundation Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) Inadequate history taking led to incorrect assumptions, nursing staff failed to follow NEWS policy for escalation, and there was confusion and non-compliance with the PE policy, highlighting a need for review.
Heather Findlay
All Responded
2023-0193 12 Jun 2023 Inner North London
East London NHS Foundation Trust Home Office Metropolitan Police Service +1 more
Concerns summary (AI summary) Staff are unprepared for patients absconding, with policies lacking clear guidance on following or police engagement, leading to confusion and potential non-attendance by police for distressed patients.
Noted (AI summary) NHS England acknowledges the concerns, states that it is not the appropriate organisation to respond to many of them, but will consider the Trust's response and has been sighted on the Trust’s Patient Safety Serious Incident Review Report. It also draws attention to NHS England’s national Mental Health, Learning Disability and Autism Inpatient Quality Transformation Programme. The MPS has the Affinity Protocol in place since 2021 and will undertake work as part of the implementation of the Right Care, Right Person to ensure policies of all parties align and there is a clear understanding of definitions and terminology used. The Home Office describes the Right Care Right Person (RCRP) approach to assist police decision making. It states that the investigation of a missing person report is an operational decision for individual police forces and refers to the MPS Affinity Protocol. The Trust has updated its Missing and AWOL policy, reviewed procedures for patients leaving acute wards, and changed observation guidance. They will review their Risk Assessment policy and the Grab Pack's alignment with local policies, including seeking external expert opinion, with a 3-6 month timescale.
Marlene McCabe
Historic (No Identified Response)
2023-0190 11 Jun 2023 Blackpool & Fylde
Bloomfield Medical Centre, Blackpool Te…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Systemic issues include a lack of clinician understanding for urgent mental health referrals, poor information sharing between providers, and a risk of misdiagnosis or delayed assessment due to assumptions about substance misuse.
Elsie Murphy
Partially Responded
2023-0189 9 Jun 2023 Cumbria
Carlisle CORONER Cumberland Council
Concerns summary (AI summary) A persistent puddle at a specific location, caused by an ineffective drain, creates an ongoing slipping hazard that has led to previous accidents and risks future falls if not remedied.
Action Taken (AI summary) Cumberland Council has clarified land ownership, installed additional drainage, and investigated potential issues with United Utilities' systems, who have now repaired their system and are monitoring it.
Alice Fox
Historic (No Identified Response)
2023-0188 9 Jun 2023 Derby and Derbyshire
University Hospitals of Derby and Burto…
Concerns summary (AI summary) The patient faced significant risk from prolonged discharge lounge stay and late night transfer without proper admission assessments. Delayed recognition and confirmation of infection, compounded by false reassurance from NEWS scores, led to missed opportunities for earlier treatment.
Hilary Guedalla
All Responded
2023-0198 8 Jun 2023 Inner North London
East London NHS Foundation Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) Multiple communication failures meant staff were unaware of a patient's high suicide risk and allowed unescorted leave. Inadequate record-keeping, brief un-noted risk assessments, and delayed, confused responses to a missing patient compounded the risk, exacerbated by short-staffing.
Action Taken (AI summary) The Trust will ensure that all ward staff are aware of service user’s leave status and clinical decisions regarding leave, and is investing £800,000 for Safer Staffing and reviewing recruitment strategy and processes.
Eifion Huws
All Responded
2023-0185 8 Jun 2023 North West Wales
Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board
Concerns summary (AI summary) Inadequate access to comprehensive patient records (due to electronic vs. hard copy discrepancies) hindered emergency staff decision-making. The Health Board's investigation also failed to address this critical information-sharing flaw or improve overall investigation timeliness.
Action Taken (AI summary) The Health Board is implementing the Welsh Community Care Information System (WCCIS) for integrated health and social care records and has reviewed its incident process, implemented rapid learning panels, and prioritized completion of overdue investigations and action plans.
David Wilson
All Responded
2023-0184 8 Jun 2023 West Yorkshire (Eastern)
Mid Yorkshire Hospitals NHS Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) The patient did not provide truly informed consent for a procedure because the standard form lacked statistical risk ratings, didn't tailor risks to his medical history, omitted the risk of death, and was signed while sedated.
Action Planned (AI summary) The Trust will refresh its consent policy ahead of its triennial review, and will work with clinical teams to ensure that as part of the consent process, the question of a patient’s capacity is considered, taken into account, and properly documented.
Ivan Ignatov
All Responded
2023-0182 8 Jun 2023 Dorset
College of Policing, National Police Ch…
Concerns summary (AI summary) A detainee's mental health assessment was missed in police custody, and an act of self-harm was misjudged. Critical risk information, including first-time custody status, was not properly recorded or collated, hindering comprehensive risk assessment.
Noted (AI summary) Dorset and Wiltshire Fire and Rescue Service states its commitment to the Joint Emergency Services Interoperability Principles (JESIP) and highlights that the challenges of intra-operability with partners is an area of focus for the Blue Light Group on 18 September 2023. Dorset Police has updated the Niche system by adding a drop-down list regarding Google Translate translation software. They are also implementing changes to Section 2 of Occurrence Logs on Niche, to prompt the Custody personnel to consider risk and vulnerability regarding the detainee in question. HM Coastguard updated its Capability Matrix to provide partner emergency services across the UK with information on its communications capabilities and uploaded it to the MCA's ResilienceDirect page. 'Connect' call capabilities also now feature in routine exercising with other stakeholders and during the Emergency Control Room visits. The National Fire Chiefs Council (NFCC) supports the consistent and robust embedding of the Joint Emergency Services Interoperability Programme (JESIP) doctrine and will commence work in autumn 2023 to establish a process of providing additional national assurance about the application of JESIP across blue light services. The Trust outlines its existing communication protocols with other emergency services, including ambulance dispatchers' ability to communicate with air ambulances and telephone links with SAR aircraft via the Maritime and Coastguard Agency. It says its staff endeavour to use clear language in all communications, adhering to JESIP principles. NHS England acknowledges concerns but notes many fall outside its remit. It encourages local systems to consider accessibility of resources and highlights agreed actions between Dorset Healthcare Criminal Justice Liaison and Diversion Team and Dorset Police to improve working practices. NicheRMS circulated the facts of the coroner's report to Niche Technology customers and is seeking views on changes needed to reduce the chance of a similar occurrence. A temporary solution is proposed, pending consultation with all Niche forces, that will involve staff making the appropriate detention log entry as occurs for other risk assessment questions. The College of Policing will amend the Detention and Custody APP checklist to include a question about previous arrests. Once this amendment has been made the College will write to forces informing them of the change. The RNLI is updating its page on the government's "ResilienceDirect" platform with details about its capabilities and pulling together material to be shared directly with emergency services partners. The RNLI will also work with the Coastguard to participate in partner awareness 'open day' events. NPAS and HMCG have agreed to a series of joint familiarisation briefings for all staff and will develop a joint "quick action card" prioritising the need for the Host Force to set an Emergency Services channel on Airwave. Monthly Comms meetings and quarterly meetings will be held and reciprocal visits between the HMCG / NPAS Ops Centres will be arranged. AACE will work with partners in police, fire and rescue, and search and rescue and the matter of concern will be discussed at the UKSAR Communications working group. The Medical Advisor to NARU is aware of the concerns and is looking to ensure learning from this tragic incident takes place.
Brenda Shields
All Responded
2023-0191 7 Jun 2023 Cumbria
Northumberland, Tyne and Wear NHS Trust
Concerns summary (AI summary) The patient was discharged without planned follow-up or family involvement, and promised referrals were not made. Inadequate consideration of her alcohol problems led to an incorrect low-risk assessment, mirroring concerns from previous reports.
Noted (AI summary) The Trust clarifies the extent of family involvement in the patient's discharge and references its Service User and Carer involvement Strategy but does not describe specific actions taken or planned in direct response to the concerns.
Anthony Smith
All Responded
2023-0187 7 Jun 2023 Lancashire and Blackburn with Darwen
HM Prison and Probation Service
Concerns summary (AI summary) The absence of protective mouth masks for resuscitation in prison exposes resuscitators to the risk of blood-borne viruses and could deter life-saving rescue breaths.
Action Taken (AI summary) The First Aid Policy Framework is being re-issued with instructions on face shield use, requiring all first aid kits to contain them and for them to be monitored. Face shields have been purchased and added to first aid boxes at HMP Preston, and staff were notified.
David Wood
All Responded
2023-0181 7 Jun 2023 Milton Keynes
John Radcliffe Hospital and MK together…
Concerns summary (AI summary) There was a failure to communicate delirium symptoms to the GP and educate the family on post-surgical discharge care, highlighting a need to review discharge protocols following heart surgery.
Action Taken (AI summary) The POA clerking proforma was amended to include previous mental health and substance use. A discharge coordinator was appointed, and the nursing team educated on support services. Consent-form stickers were updated to include delirium as a possible complication, and the process for psychological medicine referrals was clarified.
Robert Stevenson
Historic (No Identified Response)
2023-0180 7 Jun 2023 West Yorkshire (Western)
Medicines & Healthcare products Regulat…
Concerns summary (AI summary) Prescribing doctors may be unaware of a rare potential link between Ciprofloxacin/Quinolone antibiotics and suicidal behaviour, especially in depressed patients. Guidelines should be reviewed to increase awareness and mitigate this risk.
Jennifer Rackley
Historic (No Identified Response)
2023-0305 6 Jun 2023 Berkshire
Care UK
Concerns summary (AI summary) A high-risk falls patient was inadequately protected by only one sensor mat. Furthermore, the incident investigation was unrecorded, and involved staff could not be identified.
Alexander Blewitt
All Responded
2023-0207 6 Jun 2023 Milton Keynes
Milton Keynes University Hospital, Care…
Concerns summary (AI summary) The coroner notes concerns about the lack of reliable recording of intravenous fluids in the emergency department, missed points during triage, and a failure to record a major presenting symptom by the treating doctor; the Incident Investigation Report was also found to be of a poor standard.
Action Planned (AI summary) The hospital is implementing mandatory training for ED staff on referral note review, accurate medication documentation, and sepsis protocols. The Chief Nurse and Medical Director will write to all registered ED staff to emphasize key issues from the case.
Jonathan Cole
All Responded
2023-0186 5 Jun 2023 Derby and Derbyshire
Ministry of Defence Nottinghamshire Healthcare NHS Foundati…
Concerns summary (AI summary) There is a critical shortage of psychiatrists and psychologists within the Ministry of Defence, impacting serving personnel's access to appropriate mental health diagnosis and treatment, compounded by ongoing recruitment difficulties.
Noted (AI summary) The Ministry of Defence outlines existing strategies and policies related to mental health support for military personnel, transition to civilian life, and assistance to veterans and describes reviews of the Armed Forces Compensation Scheme but does not describe specific actions taken or planned in direct response to the concerns. The Trust has developed guidance for investigators to consider neurodiversity and reasonable adjustments. They will also proactively review completed investigations and upcoming inquests to identify further learning, ensure family engagement, and summarize key themes to support improvement work.
Nigel Harper
All Responded
2023-0179 2 Jun 2023 Worcestershire
Herefordshire and Worcestershire Health…
Concerns summary (AI summary) A critical communication breakdown between two NHS Trusts led to a patient with suicidal thoughts not receiving an intended urgent mental health assessment. This misunderstanding of urgent referral protocols poses a risk of future deaths.
Action Taken (AI summary) Senior managers from Gloucestershire Health & Care NHS Foundation Trust and Herefordshire & Worcestershire Health & Care Trust have met to discuss how their mental health urgent care services operate and shared operational policies. The Mental Health Liaison Team has strengthened its SOP regarding inter-trust referrals, including email confirmation and EPR entries, with an audit planned in six months. Herefordshire and Worcestershire Health and Care NHS Trust updated its standard operating procedure to clarify the nature/purpose and urgency of referrals to out-of-county emergency services, documenting the outcome on Carenotes and requiring a comprehensive assessment from the referrer.
Andrew Dean
All Responded
2023-0178 2 Jun 2023 East Sussex
HM Prison and Probation Service
Concerns summary (AI summary) There are no clear prison procedures for ensuring new prisoners can make initial family contact or for handling incoming calls from family members concerned about a prisoner's safety, posing a risk of future self-harm or suicide.
Action Taken (AI summary) HMPPS is rolling out electronic logging of safer custody concerns to all prisons by March 2024, with HMP Lewes receiving on-site support in December 2023. Staff have been instructed to record welfare calls and pass information to duty officers immediately.
Andrew Shambrook
All Responded
2023-0177 31 May 2023 North Wales East and Central
Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board
Concerns summary (AI summary) The health board lacks a robust, documented policy for decision-making and care pathways when patients are referred to the Home Treatment Team.
Action Planned (AI summary) The Health Board will review and ratify its Home Treatment Team Operational Policy by 31 January 2024, incorporating the coroner's comments. An interim addendum has been created to address immediate concerns.