Emergency services related deaths

PFD Category
Reports: 252 Areas: 59 Earliest: Jan 2016 Latest: 10 Mar 2026

85% response rate (above 62% average). 50% of classified responses show concrete action taken. Reports rose 21% from 38 (2023) to 46 (2024).

PFD Reports
252 results
Joel Colk
All Responded
2024-0621 13 Nov 2024 West Sussex, Brighton & Hove
NHS England & NHS Improvement South East Coast Ambulance Service NHS …
Concerns summary NHS Pathways' overdose categorization system fails to differentiate severity, leading to delayed responses. Ambulances also lack the necessary antidote for certain ingestions, causing critical treatment delays.
Action taken summary NHS England has commissioned a review of the NHS Pathways overdose pathways, with recommendations to be considered in February 2025 to address concerns about differentiating overdose severity. They st
Vera Spencer
All Responded
2024-0616 11 Nov 2024 Derby and Derbyshire
NHS Derby & Derbyshire Integrated Care …
Concerns summary Low ambulance service categorisation of falls leads to dangerously long waits for elderly patients, increasing risks of serious complications like pneumonia and pressure damage, exacerbated by the absence of an out-of-hours falls service.
Action taken summary Derby & Derbyshire ICB plans to accelerate the development and roll out of a falls prevention service, including consideration of an injurious falls service, in 2025/26. They will also seek to impleme
Simon Boyd
All Responded
2024-0604 6 Nov 2024 Manchester South
NHS England Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary Ambulance response times are failing national targets, and call handler scripts misleadingly imply dispatch. Additionally, ambulance responses can be cancelled without informing the caller.
Action taken summary NHS England explains the functioning of the NHS Pathways system and clarifies that exit script wording and ambulance cancellation procedures are determined locally, not nationally mandated. They sugge
Lee Armstrong
All Responded
2024-0590 29 Oct 2024 Cumbria
NHS England Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary Emergency call systems fail to solicit or share existing medical conditions with ambulance call handlers, who also lack access to patient records, risking inadequate responses for patients, particularly those with conditions causing confusion.
Action taken summary NHS England's response explains that the NHS Pathways system dynamically triggers questions about past medical history based on presenting symptoms and that comprehensive training exists for managing
Shirley Hughes
All Responded
2024-0584 28 Oct 2024 North Wales (East and Central)
Welsh Ambulance Services University NHS…
Concerns summary The Medical Priority Dispatch System (MPDS) for ambulance calls, designed years ago, is failing to meet current response targets due to resource issues, raising concerns that lives are being put at risk by outdated prioritization.
Action taken summary The Welsh Ambulance Services University NHS Trust is undertaking a comprehensive review of its Medical Priority Dispatch System (MPDS) configuration, with anticipated implementation of proposed change
Susan Shipley
All Responded
2024-0586 28 Oct 2024 North Yorkshire and York
Yorkshire Ambulance Service NHS trust
Concerns summary An amputee was incorrectly deemed 'fit to sit' for transfer without proper assessment or documentation, resulting in a fall and hip fracture. This indicates systemic failures in patient assessment and incident learning.
Action taken summary Yorkshire Ambulance Service updated its Patient Report Form in January 2024 to include mandatory fields for 'fit to sit' rationale and prompts for frail patients, and introduced a hospital portering w
Aran Bradbury
Partially Responded
2024-0572 24 Oct 2024 Norfolk
National Ambulance Service Medical Dire… NHS England Association Of Ambulance Chief Executiv…
Concerns summary The ambulance triage system incorrectly prioritised a patient with both substance ingestion and mental illness, assigning a lower category response because mental health history overshadowed drug ingestion, delaying critical aid.
Action taken summary NHS England has escalated the issue of 25-C code subsets in the AMPDS triage system to the International Academies for Emergency Dispatch for software amendment. They have also written to all ambulanc
Alice Clark
All Responded
2024-0686 24 Oct 2024 North West Kent
South East Coast Ambulance Service
Concerns summary Unsafe paramedic driving standards were not appropriately addressed due to the lack of a formal complaint procedure and inadequate independent assessment of driver competence.
Action taken summary South East Coast Ambulance Service has implemented a new driving policy (August 2023) with "Speaking Up" appendices, established a QR code and Microsoft form for reporting driving concerns, and formed
Peter Parker
All Responded
2024-0565 22 Oct 2024 SWANSEA NEATH & PORT TALBOT
WELSH ASSEMBLY GOVERNMENT WELSH AMBULANCE SERVICE NHS TRUST SWANSEA BAY UNIVERSITY HEALTH BOARD
Concerns summary Significant ambulance response delays, exceeding the expected survivability of severe injuries, were caused by ambulances being held up at Emergency Departments, preventing them from attending new calls.
Action taken summary The Welsh Ambulance Service NHS Trust acknowledges the significant delays in ambulance response but states they are not the primary authority with the power to fully resolve the systemic issues causin
Henry Willems
All Responded
2024-0569 21 Oct 2024 Worcestershire
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary Ambulance service failed to meet Category 2 response times by over two hours due to extreme surge levels and significant vehicle delays at hospitals, likely leading to the deceased's preventable death.
Action taken summary The DHSC reports that WMAS is increasing operational staff and ambulances, enhancing 'Hear and Treat' rates, and collaborating with local bodies to reduce handover delays. Nationally, the government i
Amanda Gainford
All Responded
2024-0571 21 Oct 2024 Liverpool and Wirral
NHS England
Concerns summary Unawareness among clinicians that they can challenge ambulance call categorisations by untrained handlers, or request a clinical review, can lead to critical delays in dispatch for severe cases.
Action taken summary NHS England highlights its existing National Framework for healthcare professional ambulance responses, last updated in March 2021, which details the process for HCP requests and explicitly allows cli
Gabrielle Steel
All Responded
2024-0526 3 Oct 2024 East London
London Borough of Newham London Fire Brigade
Concerns summary Critical fire safety assessment findings were not communicated by the London Fire Brigade to carers or family, preventing the implementation of a vital risk management plan for a vulnerable individual.
Action taken summary London Fire Brigade acknowledges the concerns, explaining that current policy prohibits sharing home fire safety visit findings with third parties due to data protection. However, they are reviewing t
Kevin Woods
All Responded
2024-0531 3 Oct 2024 Cornwall and Isles of Scilly
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary Persistent ambulance handover delays are linked to inadequate social and community care, with no single organisation responsible for ensuring sufficient provision or overall patient safety from these systemic failures.
Action taken summary The Department of Health and Social Care reports that Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust is implementing urgent changes to improve patient flow, including creating a Clinical Decision Unit and convert
Dennis Harry
All Responded
2024-0508 22 Sep 2024 Cornwall and Isles of Scilly
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary Inadequate social care and community health provision lead to delayed hospital discharges, causing ED crowding and systemic ambulance delays. There is no single organization responsible for ensuring sufficient social care or overseeing patient safety risks from these delays.
Action taken summary Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust is implementing urgent changes to improve patient flow and care in the emergency department, including establishing a Clinical Decision Unit and converting a Same Da
Ali Nazemi
All Responded
2024-0506 18 Sep 2024 West Yorkshire (East)
Schindler Ltd
Concerns summary A lift's uncontrolled movement device was unintentionally activated, trapping occupants with no in-lift reset or helpline solution. This caused a significant delay, posing a risk to patients needing urgent care.
Action taken summary Schindler Ltd disputes the premise that passengers activated the lift's Unintended Car Movement Protection (UCMP), clarifying it is a safety monitoring function that requires authorised personnel to r
Philip Ross
All Responded
2024-0492 16 Sep 2024 Surrey
South East Coast Ambulance Service
Concerns summary The ambulance service's failure to timely clinically validate Category 3 and 4 calls, coupled with extended response times, places deteriorating patients at risk of early death.
Action taken summary South East Coast Ambulance Service acknowledges that the 90-minute validation aim is not met for all patients. They have already optimised the use of Urgent Community Response teams, invested in contr
Margaret Huntley
All Responded
2024-0452 13 Aug 2024 Teesside and Hartlepool
North East Ambulance Service NHS Founda… Royal College of General Practitioners Association of Ambulance Chief Executiv… +1 more
Concerns summary Ambulance staff lack understanding of steroid medication importance and Addison's Crisis, with no NHS Pathways guidance for triaging. Awareness and GP use of Steroid Emergency Cards and system alerts are inadequate.
Action taken summary NHS England is collaborating with AACE and advocacy groups to enhance patient and staff awareness of steroid dependency and is monitoring NHS Pathways content. They are exploring the feasibility of cl
Sophie Wilson
All Responded
2024-0427 2 Aug 2024 Durham and Darlington.
North East Ambulance Service
Concerns summary Ambulance crews lacked crucial patient information from multi-agency plans due to electronic device data limits, necessitating manual contact with control. This compromises accessibility in emergencies for vulnerable individuals.
Action taken summary North East Ambulance Service has instructed dispatch teams to verbally notify staff of any 'flags' on patient cases. They will also cascade information to crews on accessing additional patient informa
Marjorie Michael
All Responded
2024-0408 26 Jul 2024 Gwent
Cabinet Secretary Health Social Care & …
Concerns summary Persistent lengthy ambulance response delays for critical emergencies are caused by acute hospitals failing to promptly release ambulances, despite ongoing efforts, directly contributing to patient deaths.
Action taken summary The Welsh Government highlights ongoing investment in urgent and social care capacity. Aneurin Bevan University Health Board has invested in staffing and established a new Falls Assessment Service for
Josh Smith
All Responded
2024-0402 15 Jul 2024 Kingston upon Hull & East Riding
West Yorkshire Integrated Care Board NHS England
Concerns summary Persistent ambulance response delays, both for emergency calls and hospital handovers, continue to fall short of national targets, impacting timely patient care in the community.
Action taken summary NHS England is prioritizing improving ambulance response times, reducing hospital handover delays, increasing ambulance capacity, and improving patient flow by expanding intermediate care services and
Liam McCarlie
All Responded
2024-0337 24 Jun 2024 Northamptonshire
East Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Tru… Northamptonshire Integrated Care Board
Concerns summary Mental health professionals in Emergency Operations Centres lack access to vital community mental health records, hindering informed triage and ambulance dispatch for patients with mental health needs.
Action taken summary Northamptonshire ICB and NHFT, working with EMAS, implemented a 24/7 mental health crisis service in late 2023, providing ambulance service access to mental health practitioners within an hour. EMAS i
Stefan Walker
All Responded
2024-0319 17 Jun 2024 Swansea Neath and Port Talbot
Welsh Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Concerns summary Paramedics do not routinely carry flumazenil, an antagonist that could be life-saving in acute circumstances, highlighting a potential gap in emergency medical equipment and protocols.
Action taken summary The Welsh Ambulance Service explicitly disputed the concern about not carrying flumazenil, stating it would be unsafe and against all current clinical guidelines for general overdose management. They
Robert Fray
All Responded
2024-0307 6 Jun 2024 Birmingham and Solihull
NHS England West Midlands Ambulance Service
Concerns summary NHS Pathways' 999 system failed to escalate repeated calls and its duplicate checker, relying solely on location, led to delayed and misdirected ambulance dispatch.
Action taken summary West Midlands Ambulance Service states its 999 call-taking protocols manage duplicate calls in line with established guidelines, noting that most repeat calls are for ETA and not routinely retriaged u
Bernard Compton
All Responded
2024-0304 5 Jun 2024 Manchester South
NHS England
Concerns summary The emergency department lacked effective patient oversight and systems to action urgent blood results or ECG findings, alongside failures in ambulance service assessment and timely response for a critical cardiac condition.
Sylvia Evans
All Responded
2024-0275 20 May 2024 Gwent
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board
Concerns summary An extreme 9-hour ambulance delay for a patient with a life-threatening emergency, partly caused by hospital handover issues, resulted in her death before paramedics arrived.