2024
PFD Reports
Reports: 689
Areas: 67
98% response rate (above 62% average).
Sylvia Evans
All Responded
2024-0275
20 May 2024
Gwent
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board
Concerns summary
An extreme 9-hour ambulance delay for a patient with a life-threatening emergency, partly caused by hospital handover issues, resulted in her death before paramedics arrived.
Action taken summary
Aneurin Bevan University Health Board has implemented a 100-day plan to reduce ambulance handover delays, which includes opening 19 escalation beds, commencing additional medical discharge planning wa
James Furlong, Joseph Ritchie-Bennett and David Wails
All Responded
2024-0276
20 May 2024
Central Criminal Court
Home Office
Thames Valley Police
Ministry for Justice
+4 more
Concerns summary
No specific concerns were detailed in the provided text, only a general statement about "The Failures that Contributed to the Deaths".
Action taken summary
NHS England, jointly with HMPPS, issued guidance in June 2022 to increase engagement of Prison Integrated Healthcare Teams in Pathfinder. Regional colleagues have been asked to engage with relevant Tr
Miriam Stone
All Responded
2024-0277Deceased
20 May 2024
Derby and Derbyshire
Derbyshire Healthcare NHS Trust
Concerns summary
Mental health unit admissions during staff handovers led to confusion over task allocation and risk assessment responsibility, exacerbated by the lack of a formal policy to manage or avoid admissions at these times.
Action taken summary
Derbyshire Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust has formally amended its Acute Inpatient Mental Health Services policy to include best practice guidance on avoiding patient admissions during staff shift ha
Jada Monoja
All Responded
2024-0269
17 May 2024
Inner North London
Department of Health and Social Care
South London and Maudsley NHS
NHS England
Concerns summary
An online risk assessment tool is not systematically updated or used per policy, resulting in incomplete and potentially misleading patient risk assessments, hindering effective management.
Action taken summary
NHS England acknowledges the concerns regarding risk assessment tool usage and notes that its Suicide Prevention Strategy includes actions to improve risk management and safety planning. It also highl
Jonathan Szczepanski
All Responded
2024-0271
17 May 2024
Lincolnshire
Lincolnshire Integrated Care Board
Concerns summary
Inadequate local guidance, software warnings, and discharge documentation regarding NSAID prescribing risks, including PPI use, failed to alert prescribers to critical considerations.
Action taken summary
Lincolnshire ICB plans to add a statement to the Lincolnshire Formulary and highlight NICE guidelines in newsletters and forums to address lack of guidance. They will also work with the …
Lily Jahany
All Responded
2024-0273
17 May 2024
Leicester City and South Leicestershire
Leicestershire Partnership Trust
Student Roost
Concerns summary
Student accommodation staff lacked mandatory first aid training despite residents' self-harm, and mental health teams failed to effectively gather crucial information from private psychiatrists for risk assessment, hindering comprehensive care.
Action taken summary
Student Roost has invested significantly in resident wellbeing, creating a team of advisors and training over 70 staff as Mental Health First Aiders. Following an analysis, it will train an …
Antony Waring
All Responded
2024-0399
17 May 2024
Lancashire & Blackburn with Darwen
East Lancashire Hospitals Trust
Concerns summary
A highly inappropriate surgical technique for suprapubic catheter insertion in a complex patient led to bowel perforation, compounded by inadequate use of imaging guidance and specialist consultation despite known risks.
Action taken summary
The Trust's Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) for 'Minimising the risks of supra-pubic catheter insertion in complex cases' has been approved and ratified. They have also introduced changes to clinic
Gary Ash
All Responded
2024-0228
15 May 2024
East London
Royal Colleges of Anaesthetists
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary
Significant gaps in general medical knowledge exist regarding neuroleptic malignant syndrome management, Dantrolene's adverse effects (pulmonary oedema, drug interactions), and the diagnosis of serotonin syndrome.
Action taken summary
The Royal Colleges acknowledge that anaesthetists and intensivists are taught about neuroleptic malignant syndrome and serotonin syndrome in postgraduate training. They plan to use their Patient Safet
Margaret Clement
All Responded
2024-0261
14 May 2024
Lancashire and Blackburn with Darwen
East Lancashire Teaching Hospitals
Concerns summary
Inadequate nursing records and handovers, coupled with doctors' poor task prioritisation, resulted in failures to request timely medical reviews and urgent clinical assistance for a patient with a significant bleed.
Action taken summary
East Lancashire Hospitals has implemented an enhanced nursing documentation audit tool, a Ward Manager Dashboard, and a new electronic task management system for doctors. They also developed a Consult
Carol Divall
All Responded
2024-0263
14 May 2024
East Sussex
East Sussex Healthcare NHS Trust
Concerns summary
Basic nursing failures including inadequate oral care, mobilisation, and pressure sore management led to severe deterioration. A misleading discharge summary and insufficient root cause analysis further compounded the issues.
Action taken summary
East Sussex Healthcare has implemented electronic systems for mouthcare and nutrition assessments and updated its Deteriorating Patient Policy. They have also developed a comprehensive Patient Flow do
Elvon Morton
All Responded
2024-0258
13 May 2024
East London
Barts Health NHS Foundation Trust
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary
Critical decisions were poorly documented, workload pressures led to a "coping culture," sedation decisions were flawed, and governance failed to identify and review a serious incident, compromising patient safety.
Action taken summary
The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges the coroner's concerns regarding Mr Morton's care but states that the issues are primarily for Barts Health NHS Foundation Trust to address. …
Ben Harrison
All Responded
2024-0256
10 May 2024
North Wales (East and Central)
BOC Limited
Concerns summary
Oxygen cylinders with a confusing two-valve system led to delayed oxygen delivery during resuscitation. Despite repeated incidents and training, the design remains unsafe for high-pressure medical emergencies.
Action taken summary
BOC is working with the MHRA to review regulatory requirements for integral valved oxygen cylinders and clarify roles and responsibilities, intending to meet to discuss design and supply to address …
Paul Day
All Responded
2024-0274
10 May 2024
Derby and Derbyshire
Ministry of Justice
Concerns summary
Prison CPR guidance, particularly the inclusion of rigor mortis as an exclusion, is inappropriate for untrained staff in non-24-hour healthcare facilities, risking missed opportunities for life-saving resuscitation.
Action taken summary
HMPPS acknowledges that its CPR guidance for prison officers regarding rigor mortis is less prominent than it could be and that officers are not expected to diagnose it. HMPPS will …
Samantha Angel
All Responded
2024-0253
9 May 2024
Hampshire, Portsmouth and Southampton
Queen Alexandra Hospital
Concerns summary
Delays in resolving a workplace investigation, combined with the public disclosure of allegations among colleagues, caused severe distress. The system failed to accelerate the process despite the evident harm.
Action taken summary
Portsmouth Hospitals University NHS Trust has implemented several improvements to its HR investigation processes, including a new HR governance process, a manager's toolkit, and new training for staff
Brandon Turner
All Responded
2024-0254
9 May 2024
Cornwall and the Isles of Scilly
CIOS ICB
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary
Severe staff shortages in mental health services, a lack of crisis care alternatives for complex PTSD/EUPD patients, and a two-year waiting list for autism assessments pose significant risks.
Action taken summary
The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges concerns about staff shortages, noting national progress in growing the mental health workforce and the NHS Long Term Workforce Plan's ambitions.
Linda Heath
All Responded
2024-0255
9 May 2024
East Riding and Hull
Nursing and Midwifery Council
Care Quality Commission
City Healthcare Partnership Hull
+3 more
Concerns summary
Inadequate hospital discharge summaries and a lack of GP follow-up procedures for recently discharged patients led to missed referrals for critical care. There was also an over-reliance on private care with insufficient oversight.
Action taken summary
St Andrews Surgery has implemented measures including mandatory use of the SystmOne task functionality for improved internal communication and monitoring, and has provided additional training on recor
Bobilya Mulonge
All Responded
2024-0250
8 May 2024
Manchester South
Department of Health and Social Care
Concerns summary
Persistent delays in paramedics attending Category 2 calls are caused by ambulances being unable to clear Accident and Emergency departments promptly.
Action taken summary
The Department of Health and Social Care acknowledges the concerns about ambulance response times and A&E handover delays, outlining existing national initiatives like the 'Delivery plan for recoverin
John Bass
All Responded
2024-0251
8 May 2024
Surrey
Surrey County Council
Concerns summary
Inadequate guidance for highway inspectors on vegetation encroachment on pavements and infrequent inspections of busy footpaths pose an ongoing risk to public safety.
Action taken summary
Surrey County Council disputes the need for changes to its inspection guidance for encroaching vegetation, stating pavements are for pedestrians and their policy reflects this. They also maintain that
Zarah Ravn
All Responded
2024-0252
8 May 2024
Surrey
Ashlea Medical Practice
Concerns summary
A systemic failure to conduct annual mental health and medication reviews for patients with severe mental illness, alongside a lack of risk assessment and follow-up for deteriorating mental health, created significant safety risks.
Action taken summary
Ashlea Medical Practice has implemented a new protocol for Severe Mental Illness (SMI) annual reviews and a new Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) prescribing policy since April 2024. They have also …
Sean O’Connor
All Responded
2024-0257
8 May 2024
Inner North London
Canary Wharf Management Limited
Concerns summary
The lack of mandatory checks for lone workers and failure to integrate safety discussions about required checks into routine worker briefings increased the risk of harm.
Action taken summary
Canary Wharf Management will trial a new system from July 2024, adding a mandatory prompt for contractors to request welfare checks for lone workers, which, if requested, will be conducted …
Donna Smith
All Responded
2024-0264
8 May 2024
Worcestershire
Wychavon District Council
West Mercia Police
Concerns summary
A critical lack of formal policies and guidance between CCTV operators and police led to confusion over responsibility for calling emergency services, resulting in dangerous delays.
Action taken summary
West Mercia Police has withdrawn Airwave radio from CCTV rooms, mandating all contact via telephony to ensure automatic creation of contact records and documented TRIAGE decision-making. This revised
Oliver Barnett
All Responded
2024-0348
8 May 2024
Cheshire
Department of Health and Social Care
NHS England
Concerns summary
The absence of residential substance misuse treatment facilities for children under 18 in England places them at increased risk of relapse and overdose by requiring parents to manage complex detoxification at home.
Action taken summary
NHS England states that substance misuse treatment does not fall within its remit and refers the Coroner to the Department of Health and Social Care for a response. It confirms …
Peter Fanning
All Responded
2024-0249
7 May 2024
Birmingham and Solihull
University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Fou…
Concerns summary
Insufficient radiology slots for feeding tube replacements caused week-long delays and suboptimal nutrition for complex patients. There was also a lack of clear procedures for maintaining nutrition during these delays.
Action taken summary
University Hospitals Birmingham has increased its Interventional Radiology (IR) capacity from one to four lists per week and increased IR consultants, with these changes in place since April 2024. The
Matthew Scott
All Responded
2024-0355
7 May 2024
Derby and Derbyshire
REDACTED
Concerns summary
A lengthy, defective, and subsided section of road, prone to holding standing water that could freeze, created a significant hazard for drivers, leading to loss of vehicle control.
Action taken summary
Derbyshire County Council disputes the coroner's description of a significant road defect, citing a laser survey and routine inspections. However, they have scheduled full-width road surfacing work fo
Peter Dickens
All Responded
2024-0286
6 May 2024
Nottinghamshire
Cygnet Health Care
Concerns summary
Persistent staff non-compliance with eating and drinking guidelines, coupled with management's failure to understand and monitor these issues, and inadequate provision of funded support, compromised patient care.
Action taken summary
Cygnet Health Care has implemented significant changes, including a new registered manager, mandatory e-learning on eating and drinking, a new choking risk assessment, a new Safe and Wellbeing Review