Quality of police investigations
Investigation management, prioritisation, urgency, early prosecutor advice, evidence handling.
40 inquiry recommendations
Public inquiry recommendations
What public inquiries recommended · 40 recommendations
Jump to year: 2026 2025 2024 2022 2021 2019 2012 2003 2000 1999
2026
The Inquiry Panel recommends that the PSNI ensures that where officers of whatever rank use a personal journal or any other book for recording evidence and policy/strategy, such books are available for inspection and upon completion stored securely on police premises to meet disclosure requirements.
The Inquiry Panel recommends that the PSNI reviews the role of supervisory officers and the requirement to monitor notebook entries on a regular basis and, on a random basis, compare entries with statements of evidence.
The Inquiry Panel recommends that the PSNI identifies any necessary additional training for officers in relation to the gathering of evidence and preparation of statements. This could be done through officers’ personal development plans and quality control checks.
The Inquiry Panel acknowledges the developments in gathering and using scientific evidence made by the PSNI and reported on by CJNI/HMIC in 2005 and 2007. The report in 2007 highlights that there are still issues regarding officers’ awareness of scientific issues. As this is a developing area the PSNI should consider…
The Panel recommends the use of command and control systems to record operational decisions and actions at the scene, allowing the decision-maker and any other officer to check that each task has been performed and recorded.
The Inquiry Panel recommends that the PSNI ensures that officers are debriefed by a supervisory officer at the completion of a tour of duty and that any intelligence or evidence gathered is correctly disseminated.
The Inquiry Panel recommends that the PSNI examines the level of training given to uniformed supervisors and constables on their role at a major crime scene. The Panel notes that despite the training which is in place, not all officers did what they were trained to do. This calls for an examination of the adequacy of…
PSNI needs to improve its processes for the review of live investigation files, and have an effective escalation process when progress is delayed. PSNI should consider how it assures the quality of the reviews of live investigation files. Senior officers should assess a significant sample of reviews to ensure all…
1. Lancashire Constabulary should ensure response officers have access to effective technology providing clear, essential case information. 2. The National Police Chiefs’ Council, College of Policing and Home Office should review whether current policing information systems, particularly the limitations on cross‑force…
Lancashire Constabulary should ensure its training and systems address the risks associated with failing to record case information on police systems so it is readily available to others. The National Police Chiefs’ Council and College of Policing should consider whether further national guidance is required.
Lancashire Constabulary, and the College of Policing nationally, should ensure that forms and training emphasise the importance of recording, as precisely as possible, the words and behaviour of individuals who may pose a significant risk to others.
2025
By March 2026, the College of Policing and the National Centre for Violence Against Women and Girls and Public Protection, working with the National Police Chiefs' Council and the Crown Prosecution Service, should create a consistent and clear standard for police investigations in this area, explicitly addressing the…
By March 2026, the Home Office, working with the National Police Chiefs' Council, and the National Centre for Violence Against Women and Girls and Public Protection, should agree plans for the full, consistent and sustainable implementation of Operation Soteria across all forces in England and Wales. This should…
2024
By December 2024, the College of Policing, in collaboration with the National Police Chiefs' Council, should improve guidance and training on indecent exposure, in order to improve the quality of investigations and management of indecent exposure cases. In particular, the College of Policing should: a. review and…
At the earliest opportunity, and by September 2024 at the latest, police forces should ensure that they have a specialist policy on investigating all sexual offences, including so-called 'non-contact' offences, such as indecent exposure.
2022
APP-AP should be amended to cover the following: a. Sustained public protection should never be the object of an operation unless and until there is a clearly recorded note of the possible charge(s) that are anticipated, the evidence that will be required to establish guilt, the evidential (and, if appropriate,…
2021
All independent panels and inquiries examining police investigations should be given full access to the associated HOLMES accounts at their secure premises when they begin their work.
The Metropolitan Police should ensure that the role of the Family Liaison Officer is never carried out by the Senior Investigating Officer of an investigation. There is an inherent conflict between these two roles.
The HOLMES system is both an investigative tool and a quality assurance mechanism, but it requires significant resources if it is to be used properly. The Panel recommends that the Metropolitan Police conduct an investigation into the adequacy of resources for administering HOLMES in major crime investigations carried…
It is recommended that the Metropolitan Police introduce systems to ensure that the management arrangements which applied during the Abelard Two Investigation can never be replicated in any future investigation, and that proper management arrangements, in compliance with the Association of Chief Police Officers'…
The Panel recommends that the Metropolitan Police consider the desirability and explore the possibility of obtaining samples of DNA from former Police Officer Z31's relatives, to compare it with the outstanding DNA recovered from the axe.
The Panel has received advice from an independent forensic science expert it consulted, Dr [name] that useful work could still be carried out on this document. It therefore recommends that the Metropolitan Police considers the operational benefits of submitting the diary for a forensic handwriting analysis in order to…
2019
Greater Manchester Police (“GMP”) should design and promulgate a written policy that specifically relates to the collection, analysis and dissemination of intelligence for the purposes of planned armed deployments within the meaning of the Armed Policing module of Authorised Professional Practice (“APP”). While it…
2012
The Information Commissioner's Office should take immediate steps to engage with the Metropolitan Police on the preparation of a long-term strategy in relation to alleged media crime with a view to ensuring that the Office is well placed to fulfil any necessary role in this respect in the future, and in particular in…
2003
Chief constables must ensure that officers working on child protection teams are sufficiently well trained in criminal investigation, and that there is always a substantial core of fully trained detective officers on each team to deal with the most serious inquiries.
Every record on this page is an inquiry recommendation published by the inquiry named on its card, and each card links to the recommendation. The themes, and which recommendations sit under each, are our own classification.