Inquiries / Themes / Public finance, projects and government

Major project delivery

Cost overruns, schedule delay, scope uncertainty, assurance and lessons learned on major projects.

38 inquiry recommendations

Public inquiry recommendations

What public inquiries recommended · 38 recommendations

Jump to year: 2025 2023 2020 1989

2025

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-3
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to Scottish Government

It is critical that a health board formulates and then presents its requirements for the key building systems in a proposed healthcare facility (its "brief") in terms which are full, clear, and unambiguous, and that that brief is finalised before a contract is signed and Financial Close is achieved. While development…

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-10
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to Scottish Government

This issue was highlighted in the [name] report where similar recommendations are made to what is set out above. NHSL has taken steps to address the issue. However, it is not clear from the available evidence that any such changes have taken place more widely within the NHS. I accordingly recommend that a uniform…

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-9
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to Scottish Government

I accordingly recommend that a similar procedure should be considered when technical advisers (particularly engineers) are providing specific technical advice in relation to a project such as the RHCYP and DCN. There should be a clear record of the advice requested, and the advice tendered. This should ensure that…

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-7
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to Scottish Government

It is clearly desirable that a health board has the assurance prior to the handover of a new or refurbished healthcare facility that the facility's specialised ventilation systems have been independently validated by an Authorising Engineer as fit for purpose and capable of achieving the operating performance…

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-5
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to NHS Scotland Assure

A range of procedures now exists to help ensure health board projects meet appropriate standards. One is the NHS Scotland Design Assessment Process ("NDAP"). There is also a Sustainable Design and Construction Procedure ("SDAC"). In addition, there is the NHS Scotland Assure Key Stage Assurance Review (KSAR)…

Scottish Hospitals Inquiry Recommendation SHI-2
4 Mar 2025
Addressed to Scottish Government

Accordingly, in situations where the funding model or procurement route changes mid project, a risk assessment should be conducted to assess whether work done on the project up to that point is suitable for the revised project. The rationale for decisions taken in this regard should be formally recorded. The party…

2023

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-24
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The Scottish Ministers should also give consideration to the need for legislation to impose a similar duty of disclosure to that owed by policyholders to their insurers upon a company, its directors, employees or consultants and upon a local authority and its officials towards representatives of OGC or of Audit…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-21
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

Local authority officials should be mindful at all times of the distinction in roles between them and councillors, who are solely responsible for strategic decisions, and of their duty to provide accurate reports to councillors to enable them to take informed decisions based upon the reality of the situation. Such…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-20
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

The directors, employees and consultants of the company responsible for the procurement and delivery of the project as project managers, including an arm’s-length external organisation (“ALEO”) wholly owned by the local authority that is the promoter and owner of the project, should not submit to the local authority…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-19
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

At all stages of the project there should be a collaborative approach to delivering it. This should include the co-location of representatives from each organisation relevant to the particular stage reached and having an interest in its completion to enable any issues to be addressed and resolved at the earliest…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-18
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

As part of their investigations, representatives of OGC undertaking an independent “readiness review” of a publicly funded project and representatives of any person, including representatives of any public body such as Audit Scotland, undertaking a review of the progress of and/or expenditure on a project funded in…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-17
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

The governance structure for the delivery of a major project such as a light rail scheme should follow the published guidance and should ensure that there is clarity regarding the respective roles of the various bodies and individuals involved in its delivery. In particular, the chairman of the company responsible for…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-16
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

Immediately following the appointment of the designer, and throughout the design of the project, the designer should engage with the promoter and owner of the project, the procurement and project manager, the local planning authority, the utility companies and interested third parties owning land that may be affected…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-15
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to City of Edinburgh Council

In recognition of the various difficulties likely to be experienced in the design and construction of a light rail project through a city centre, the promoter and owner of the project should appoint as its procurement and project manager a company with suitably qualified and experienced permanent employees that has…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-14
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

Although some participants in the Inquiry criticised the use of MUDFA to divert utilities in advance of the infrastructure works and advocated the “bow wave” approach to the diversion of utilities that followed the mediation settlement at Mar Hall, I do not think it appropriate to be prescriptive about how the risks…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-13
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The procurement strategy for any future light rail project should make adequate provision for the uncertainties concerning the location of utilities and redundant equipment belonging to present and past utility companies, particularly in urban centres. In particular, although it is not possible to be prescriptive…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-11
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The Scottish Ministers and local authorities responsible for funding light rail projects should be mindful at all times of their obligation to protect public funds and to obtain value for public expenditure. In that regard: • the Scottish Ministers should impose conditions on the payments of grants, similar to the…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-10
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

In the interests of protecting the public purse and maximising the benefits from public expenditure on major projects, the Scottish Ministers should contemplate establishing a joint working group consisting of officials in Transport Scotland and representatives of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (“COSLA”)…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-9
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The identification and management of risk should be an integral part of the governance of all major public-sector contracts in future. In identifying and managing risk the following principles should be adopted: • Probabilistic forecasts rather than single-point forecasts should be used to take account of the risk…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-8
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The existing Guidance on optimism bias was based on empirical data available almost two decades ago and should be revised to take into account the additional data that is now available. In particular, the reference classes should be updated to include a specific reference to light rail projects and the recommended…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-7
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

The assessment of risk at each stage mentioned in Recommendation 6 should be the subject of a peer review by external consultants with experience of similar large-scale infrastructure projects in the transportation sector who should submit a report of each review to the promoter and owner of the project as well as to…

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-6
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

All versions of the Business Case, including any Business Case required as a result of altered assumptions, should include an assessment of risk that takes account of optimism bias in accordance with the current published government guidance.

Edinburgh Tram Inquiry Recommendation ETI-5
19 Sep 2023
Addressed to Scottish Government

Where the Business Case for any future light rail project is based upon an assumption that, prior to the award of the contract for the construction of the infrastructure, certain matters will have been completed (e.g. design, the obtaining of all necessary approvals and consents or the diversion of utilities), the…

2020

Renewable Heat Incentive Inquiry Recommendation RHI-44
13 Mar 2020
Addressed to NI Audit Office

The recommendations for change made here, to the extent they are adopted, will take time to implement; they may indeed not even be sufficient to address the range of shortcomings revealed by the Inquiry. The Inquiry therefore recommends a role in future for the Northern Ireland Audit Office in assessing and validating…

Renewable Heat Incentive Inquiry Recommendation RHI-22
13 Mar 2020
Addressed to Department of Finance

Particularly where a policy initiative is demand-led, novel, complex and/or likely to be lengthy, consideration should be given to increasing Department of Finance involvement from an early stage and on an ongoing basis, including a more proactive role in monitoring the financial progress of the relevant initiative,…

Page 1 of 2 Next

Every record on this page is an inquiry recommendation published by the inquiry named on its card, and each card links to the recommendation. The themes, and which recommendations sit under each, are our own classification.

Licensing and attribution for every source